Mongano vs Black Cherry

[dusty paws]

Mogano is simply stunning - you won't be disappointed!

 

[mintpearl]

Mine too

Ditto!Mogano is also my fave bal brown ever! And the best color for the sgh PT in my opinion! luv luv luv it!!!

oogi and deco: your mogano PT's are amazing!

so in answer to the OP's question: Get the mogano! You won't be sorry! Every mogano I came across had the best leather 07 had to offer: thick, wrinkly, chewy, chevre perfection!

 

[chinkee21]

If you could, maybe wait to see the BC IRL? Though Mogano is a gorgeous color too!!

 

[kristie]

Good choice on the Mogano! It is a TDF perfect color

 

[Deco]

Ditto!Mogano is also my fave bal brown ever! And the best color for the sgh PT in my opinion! luv luv luv it!!!

oogi and deco: your mogano PT's are amazing!

so in answer to the OP's question: Get the mogano! You won't be sorry! Every mogano I came across had the best leather 07 had to offer: thick, wrinkly, chewy, chevre perfection!

Righto again! Fabulous, transcendental leather, every single time!! Vert Fonce is the same in terms of consistently luscious leather. Mogano ROCKS!!

 

[REREsaurus]

Thanks for your help everyone....i think I'm just going to go for it and get the mongano!

Excellent choice. Mogano, yes, as mentioned by a billion ladies on tPF, has some thee best leather I've ever seen. Mom's Mogano City SGH is stunning!

Though, there has been a report by dear aki_sato that she really liked the leathers she has seen on some new FW 08 bags. She saw 'em in Paris!

 

[amiekbs8]

Glad you chose Mogano! (Hey, you can get Black Cherry too if the color is very distinct!) I love the leather on all Moganos, and you def won't be disappointed!

 

[mmmsc]

Mine too

I have a Mogano Day RW and it is SO beautiful. It looks like 2005 Chocolate.

 

[lovely64]

My vote goes to the mogano, stunning colour although black cherry looks lovely too but hard to say before having seen it IRL,

kat

 

[clarimond]

Here are some comparison pictures for your references:

Left: Black Cherry
Right: Cinnamon (mogano)

Top: Cinnamon
Bottom: Black Cherry

 

[amiekbs8]

AHHH! clarimond you are a saint! Your pics are spectacular!!! Black Cherry is making my heart jump!

 

[rollergirl]

It looks just how the old picture I saw looked, dark tone of Bordeaux with more of the redness of Grenat. Yay.

 

[OMGxBecky]

Here are some comparison pictures for your references:

Thanks for the great pics Clarimond. Both of your bags are are beautiful. I am in Love with Black Cherry!

 

[drati]

Great comparison, thanks for posting Clarimond.

Congrats on your new courier, looks gorgeous.

 

[bellini]

clarimond, thanks a billion for the great comparison shots. nearly drowned in red-brown paradise! i think fw leather has hope yet!! the black cherry is gorgeous!