Michael Kors MICHAEL KORS Astor TOTE vs. SATCHEL vs. RANGER!

[KoobaLover]

My vote goes to the Astor Satchel.

 

[dierregi]

I like the Astor tote the best. The third is also nice but too much hardware

 

[HuskyLover]

Wow, nobody likes the Ranger! I like all three in different ways, but if I had to choose just one it would probably be the tote. They really are 3 very different bags, go with you gut feeling!

 

[haftime]

I own the astor satchel in black w/ gold hardware-- I love it because it is a classic style that will last. It's been Michael Kors signature bag for years, so though he may keep "updating" it (like the astor tote), he's gonna keep making that satchel.

 

[Lexie2000]

Ummmm...this is so hard.

Not Really!!!

SATCHEL!!!!! It's sooooo classy. I gotta get me one!

 

[louislover260]

I think the ranger is fun... I saw the tote in person, the straps are a nightmare!

 

[sweetneet]

i love the second one.

 

[pursefan06]

I love the satchel, it is one of my favorites by MK, it is really pretty in the Cherry also!

 

[jchiara]

Ummmm...this is so hard.

Not Really!!!

SATCHEL!!!!! It's sooooo classy. I gotta get me one!

You already had one Lex! And sold it!!!!!

 

[jchiara]

I think the ranger is fun... I saw the tote in person, the straps are a nightmare!

Hey Louislover - nice to see you on the thread! Don't kill me everyone, but it actually worked out quite nicely last night. Me and DH after our "hot date" (not really) went over to Nordies and lo and behold! They had ALL the MK bags right there! Granted, they were in a color I wasn't interested in (luggage) but oh my gosh - I could try them all out in PERSON!!!!

Ranger - lost my interest...didn't have it anyway and it was the lowest on my list....

Satchel - cute - really cute....kinda small (even the large one)...."eh" was my response. it think I would have liked it in a brighter color - like I would jump on a cherry one!!!

Tote - WHAT A PLEASANT SURPRISE! Seriously, no problems having it over your shoulder AT ALL! And I even had a shirt and a denim jacket on and it was FINE!!! Size was good, really neat snap top so it wasn't completely open and I liked the way it cinched at the top.....so I ran home and snagged me the one that I REALLY wanted which was the TOTE IN GUNMETAL GREY! I'm psyched! I promise to post pics when I receive it!!!!!
now I think I need a wallet AND the cherry satchel.....

 

[divalicioust]

Hey Louislover - nice to see you on the thread! Don't kill me everyone, but it actually worked out quite nicely last night. Me and DH after our "hot date" (not really) went over to Nordies and lo and behold! They had ALL the MK bags right there! Granted, they were in a color I wasn't interested in (luggage) but oh my gosh - I could try them all out in PERSON!!!!

Ranger - lost my interest...didn't have it anyway and it was the lowest on my list....

Satchel - cute - really cute....kinda small (even the large one)...."eh" was my response. it think I would have liked it in a brighter color - like I would jump on a cherry one!!!

Tote - WHAT A PLEASANT SURPRISE! Seriously, no problems having it over your shoulder AT ALL! And I even had a shirt and a denim jacket on and it was FINE!!! Size was good, really neat snap top so it wasn't completely open and I liked the way it cinched at the top.....so I ran home and snagged me the one that I REALLY wanted which was the TOTE IN GUNMETAL GREY! I'm psyched! I promise to post pics when I receive it!!!!!
now I think I need a wallet AND the cherry satchel.....

I agree; I own the tote and I have no problems with the straps.​

 

[ValleyO]

Congrats! The tote was definitely my favorite!