May I Pick Your Brain: Cartier or Tiffany Ring?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

If you’re going to check out the Tiffany one in person, you should look at the new Knot collection rings while you’re there. The larger version (I think it’s called the double row) ring comes in rose gold pave and could check the boxes of what you’re looking for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zoeshin and lxrac
I prefer the Cartier rings. The Tiffany ring reminds me of a Cartier Trinity ring that is missing 1 band. I haven't been a fan of Tiffany in a long time. Other than maybe a diamond engagement ring, I just don't think they are on the same level as Cartier, VCA, or Bvlgari.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lxrac
If you’re going to check out the Tiffany one in person, you should look at the new Knot collection rings while you’re there. The larger version (I think it’s called the double row) ring comes in rose gold pave and could check the boxes of what you’re looking for.

Wow! You are so correct. The pavé version is amazing. Now you officially made my selection process harder. :angel:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ready2wear
I prefer the Cartier rings. The Tiffany ring reminds me of a Cartier Trinity ring that is missing 1 band. I haven't been a fan of Tiffany in a long time. Other than maybe a diamond engagement ring, I just don't think they are on the same level as Cartier, VCA, or Bvlgari.

Thanks for the input. I see half are more into Cartier and half are into Tiffany. I on the other hand don't know know which way to go. haha :angel::nuts::graucho:
 
I haven't decided which one to get yet but I wanted to add to the choices: RG small version of the Cartier pavé ring-just to add a little variety of style in my collection.4A6E445C-7890-4141-9C7E-CA4C7E8BBD3C.jpeg
It's going to be a long process of elimination. I'm also going to check out the Tiffany knot pavé ring that a previous poster recommended in December. :noworry:
 
Get Cartier or unbranded, Tiffany's brand value has really gone to high school girl birthday gift vibe

I agree! My engagement and wedding rings are Tiffany, and up until this year I was planning on getting another Tiffany ring to stack with them for my 5 year anniversary, but never will I again buy Tiffany. I think of my rings from the "before HSGBGV times". :cool:
 
Top