Magic Pendant - MOP or Guilloche

Magic Pendant Choice

  • MOP

    Votes: 70 54.7%

  • Guilloche

    Votes: 59 46.1%
  • Total voters
    128

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

#16
lynne_ross said:
I will not be helpful since not a fan of guilloche but Of your options I would save for dismond in magic and get something else in vintage (mop, malachite,onyx, etc). For mop the inbetween magic and vintage is a nice size too. It doesn’t have as much length option with the chain but it is such a great size.
Click to expand...

Maybe VCA should consider a in-between size for the Pave as well, if people do not wear the Pave as a long necklace...
 
  • Like
Reactions: J_love_Chanel
Shop Van Cleef & Arpels at Fashionphile
#17
Guesswho said:
Yes - guilloche is much shinier.
So maybe get MOP magic for day time, and start saving for the Pave magic for the evening under the road...
Click to expand...

I think this would be a perfect combination. I love the guilloche, and if it was vintage size I would definitely say opt for guilloche, but I think the Magic guilloche yg is a little loud for day time. I could even see the pave being worn in daytime.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J_love_Chanel
#18
Guesswho said:
I am considering adding a long necklace to my collection. I have my eyes on the Magic Pendant. I have a hard time to decide between MOP and Guilloche. They are both easy to match colors. Guilloche is solid gold, more durable, at a higher price point. MOP is the classic, elegant, but may be subject to scratches, since I intend to wear it long?

What would the best choice?
Click to expand...

I vote MOP magic, love mine!

jenaywins said:
MOP. The Guilloche is too much in the Magic size IMO.

Actually, my vote is for you to buy the MOP Magic and Guilloche Vintage. :yes:



Thank me later. ;)
Click to expand...

Thank you! My two most recent additions are the WG magic MOP and WG Guilloche 2020 holiday pendant. Love them both!
 
#25
Guesswho said:
I am considering adding a long necklace to my collection. I have my eyes on the Magic Pendant. I have a hard time to decide between MOP and Guilloche. They are both easy to match colors. Guilloche is solid gold, more durable, at a higher price point. MOP is the classic, elegant, but may be subject to scratches, since I intend to wear it long?

What would the best choice?
Click to expand...
If this is your first magic pendant then my vote is for mop. It’s a more versatile imo, which can be dressed up or down. The guilloche is stunning but I feel it’s more dressy?
BTW I do have the malachite magic pendant and it’s much more fragile than mop. However, no scratches on or issues with my pendant. Looks as brand new as the day I bought it, which was probably 3-4 years back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chinamom and hhw
#26
Guesswho said:
I am considering adding a long necklace to my collection. I have my eyes on the Magic Pendant. I have a hard time to decide between MOP and Guilloche. They are both easy to match colors. Guilloche is solid gold, more durable, at a higher price point. MOP is the classic, elegant, but may be subject to scratches, since I intend to wear it long?

What would the best choice?
Click to expand...

MOP. I love Guilloche in vintage, however in magic it is very shiny and I am not sure if it is wearable everyday.
 
#29
Guesswho said:
My SA is pushing me to the Guilloche. Her rationale is Guilloche is the newer option, and MOP is out for a long time - many already have it. Does anyone have both of them, or consider getting both of them?
Click to expand...
I have both magic pendants and I am very happy with them, so far no scratches on the MOP but I see a slight wear on the Guilloche even though it is a new piece :wtf:

I find it easy to dress the MOP but the Guilloche is a bit tricky. Just my opinion :) but I am sure one of the pieces will speak to you and you will choose the one your heart picks!
 
  • Like
Reactions: hhw
#30
ayshaa said:
I have both magic pendants and I am very happy with them, so far no scratches on the MOP but I see a slight wear on the Guilloche even though it is a new piece :wtf:

I find it easy to dress the MOP but the Guilloche is a bit tricky. Just my opinion :smile: but I am sure one of the pieces will speak to you and you will choose the one your heart picks!
Click to expand...

I’ve been considering the magic Guilloche too and am bummed to hear that you are seeing sign of wear on yours. It’s such a striking statement piece.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top