These are so hard to find now! I just bought two new Haileys on eBay, one of the original older model #14304 and one of the newer Hailey #18633. I feel so fortunate to have found them on eBay and have actually been looking for several years there for them. I had an original #14304 Hailey and foolishly sold it about 6 months after I'd bought it from
Coach. Have regretted it ever since. Most of the ones I've found on eBay have been really beat up so I kept waiting for a 'new' condition listings to appear.
I got a new #14304 Hailey in Black, perfect condition, and a new #18633 in Mahogany - beautiful. I do like the leather on the #18633 Hailey much better - it's so soft and smushy and feels better. I like the differences in the detailing between the two bags so each has their good points.
I will definitely hang on to these as they are
INCREDIBLY difficult to find as resale.

And understandably so, as they're beautiful, versatile and hold a lot for a small-medium bag. My advice to anyone on here with a Hailey is
DO NOT resell it. You will have an incredibly difficult time trying to get another one if you search eBay.
Another word of caution: Also, I purchased one on line about 2 years ago and it was a FACTORY Hailey. It had the F before the #18633 and you could tell the quality difference immediately. I gave it a go as I had no luck in finding the full price versions on eBay. I ended up selling it back on eBay as the quality was just not there - zipper was rough when opening/closing and the leather quality felt different. I don't like how Coach makes factory versions of some of their FP bags for the outlets. Like the Phoebe - I'm seeing small Phoebe's on eBay that are factory ones and I imagine the quality is not nearly as nice as the original Phoebe which I have.