I’ve both bags and I love them both for different purposes. If what you’re looking for is a casual bag then perhaps I would lean towards the vanity. But bear in mind that the capacity is smaller so it also depends on how much you carry - otherwise a similar style would be the nice, that has a few sizes depending on your needs. I hardly wear my capucines with casual clothing and realize I reach for it less often as i find it formal looking. It also is quite heavy on its own like someone mentioned above. Mine’s the BB size and when filled up it’s heavier. I suggest you try on both at the store in your usual outfit and see which goes?