Let's discuss Cartier necklaces!

[isabelmidori]

Hello everybody! I have a question for you guys and need some advice. I generally don't buy jewerly very often and I only have some costume earrings from chanel and dior previously. And recently I started my fine jewelry collection and it's pretty limited compared to most of you. Right now I have: VCA magic mop clip on earrings, perlee signature bracelet in rose gold, sweet 6 motif rose gold alhambra bracelet, vca btf butterfly ring in mop and pave (yes i finally pulled the trigger and i love it so so much!!).

Most recently, I purchased a C De Cartier rose gold chain necklace with the diamond being 0.5 carat. Keep in mind that I don't have any other necklaces (not even any fashion jewelry necklaces). I am not sure whether I should return this necklace and get another bangle (from VCA or another instead) instead or maybe keep it? Here are some of my thoughts:

1. I don't think I should stack my perlee signature bangle with the sweet 6 motif because it would scratch and get tangled. however, if i wear perlee on one wrist and sweet 6 motif on another wrist it looks a bit...unconventional. But I think if i stack the perlee signature with another bangle on one wrist and then wear the sweet 6 motif on another wrist, then it would look good. However, I am not sure which other bangle to get. Any ideas?
2. I thought about returning the c de cartier necklace and get a skinny love bangle to stack with perlee, though i have never seen this combination. But then I won't have any necklaces. But then again I have noticed most people don't wear earrings+necklace+bracelets. It seems like it's better to just do earrings+bracelet OR necklace+bracelet OR earrings+necklace. I want something I can wear every day.
3 So based on my small collection, should I return the c de cartier necklace and get another bangle intead? Suppose I can only have one but not both

 

[Babsiegirl]

Hello everybody! I have a question for you guys and need some advice. I generally don't buy jewerly very often and I only have some costume earrings from chanel and dior previously. And recently I started my fine jewelry collection and it's pretty limited compared to most of you. Right now I have: VCA magic mop clip on earrings, perlee signature bracelet in rose gold, sweet 6 motif rose gold alhambra bracelet, vca btf butterfly ring in mop and pave (yes i finally pulled the trigger and i love it so so much!!).

Most recently, I purchased a C De Cartier rose gold chain necklace with the diamond being 0.5 carat. Keep in mind that I don't have any other necklaces (not even any fashion jewelry necklaces). I am not sure whether I should return this necklace and get another bangle (from VCA or another instead) instead or maybe keep it? Here are some of my thoughts:

1. I don't think I should stack my perlee signature bangle with the sweet 6 motif because it would scratch and get tangled. however, if i wear perlee on one wrist and sweet 6 motif on another wrist it looks a bit...unconventional. But I think if i stack the perlee signature with another bangle on one wrist and then wear the sweet 6 motif on another wrist, then it would look good. However, I am not sure which other bangle to get. Any ideas?
2. I thought about returning the c de cartier necklace and get a skinny love bangle to stack with perlee, though i have never seen this combination. But then I won't have any necklaces. But then again I have noticed most people don't wear earrings+necklace+bracelets. It seems like it's better to just do earrings+bracelet OR necklace+bracelet OR earrings+necklace. I want something I can wear every day.
3 So based on my small collection, should I return the c de cartier necklace and get another bangle intead? Suppose I can only have one but not both

I would keep the necklace. Half carat is a great size!! When I go out I have my watch on my left and at least a couple of bracelets on my right wrist, earrings always as my hair is short, and I always wear a necklace. Some may say it’s too much, but I’ve been doing it for years. It’s whatever makes you comfortable. Would love to see a pic of the necklace!

 

[shinelove20]

Hello everybody! I have a question for you guys and need some advice. I generally don't buy jewerly very often and I only have some costume earrings from chanel and dior previously. And recently I started my fine jewelry collection and it's pretty limited compared to most of you. Right now I have: VCA magic mop clip on earrings, perlee signature bracelet in rose gold, sweet 6 motif rose gold alhambra bracelet, vca btf butterfly ring in mop and pave (yes i finally pulled the trigger and i love it so so much!!).

Most recently, I purchased a C De Cartier rose gold chain necklace with the diamond being 0.5 carat. Keep in mind that I don't have any other necklaces (not even any fashion jewelry necklaces). I am not sure whether I should return this necklace and get another bangle (from VCA or another instead) instead or maybe keep it? Here are some of my thoughts:

1. I don't think I should stack my perlee signature bangle with the sweet 6 motif because it would scratch and get tangled. however, if i wear perlee on one wrist and sweet 6 motif on another wrist it looks a bit...unconventional. But I think if i stack the perlee signature with another bangle on one wrist and then wear the sweet 6 motif on another wrist, then it would look good. However, I am not sure which other bangle to get. Any ideas?
2. I thought about returning the c de cartier necklace and get a skinny love bangle to stack with perlee, though i have never seen this combination. But then I won't have any necklaces. But then again I have noticed most people don't wear earrings+necklace+bracelets. It seems like it's better to just do earrings+bracelet OR necklace+bracelet OR earrings+necklace. I want something I can wear every day.
3 So based on my small collection, should I return the c de cartier necklace and get another bangle intead? Suppose I can only have one but not both

I would also keep the necklace - I think necklaces add such a nice touch of glow to our faces, even tho it's hard to look down and admire them unlike bracelets haha which are fantastic eye candy. Maybe you can start growing your bracelet collection slowly now!

 

[dm213]

Hi everyone, I could use your help with choosing a size of the diamants legers necklace. I would like to get one for my wife as a push gift because I know that she has wanted a new yellow gold diamond pendant necklace for daily wear. I am having trouble choosing between sizes. There seem to be more posts of size small, but I am unsure if people more commonly choose that over the size large due to price or aesthetics. It may be too subjective for anyone to really help, but I thought it was worth asking. If it matters for sizing, my wife is petite (5’2” and a small frame). I am just unsure whether the large or small would be better for daily wear and maybe layering other necklaces on occasion. Thank you for any help!

 

[vvendyu]

Hi everyone, I could use your help with choosing a size of the diamants legers necklace. I would like to get one for my wife as a push gift because I know that she has wanted a new yellow gold diamond pendant necklace for daily wear. I am having trouble choosing between sizes. There seem to be more posts of size small, but I am unsure if people more commonly choose that over the size large due to price or aesthetics. It may be too subjective for anyone to really help, but I thought it was worth asking. If it matters for sizing, my wife is petite (5’2” and a small frame). I am just unsure whether the large or small would be better for daily wear and maybe layering other necklaces on occasion. Thank you for any help!

First off, congratulations! Secondly, I think most people choose the diamanté leger line because they want a very dainty diamond. If your wife likes dainty jewelry, you can’t go wrong with a leger. I have the small and I think it’s so sweet and dainty. But you can not go wrong with a bigger diamond. I don’t think you wife will be unhappy with a larger diamond

 

[Chaton]

Hi everyone, I could use your help with choosing a size of the diamants legers necklace. I would like to get one for my wife as a push gift because I know that she has wanted a new yellow gold diamond pendant necklace for daily wear. I am having trouble choosing between sizes. There seem to be more posts of size small, but I am unsure if people more commonly choose that over the size large due to price or aesthetics. It may be too subjective for anyone to really help, but I thought it was worth asking. If it matters for sizing, my wife is petite (5’2” and a small frame). I am just unsure whether the large or small would be better for daily wear and maybe layering other necklaces on occasion. Thank you for any help!

I agree with the above - go for the larger size diamond. I am petite and have tried this necklace on before - the whole Diamants Légers line contain relatively small size diamonds so they can easily be worn for everyday.

 

[dm213]

Thank you both for the advice! I think that you’re right — she is not going to be unhappy about the larger diamond, especially since it’s still relatively dainty/small. Now I just need to make an appointment at one of the nearby Cartier locations. After reading about some of the experiences that people have had ordering online, it seems better to go in store...or at least order from the store over the phone.

 

[Chaton]

Today I tried on the C de Cartier Diamond Necklace as well as the 1895 Necklace.

1st Pic: C de Cartier
Both PG size .30ct (G, VS1) and .50ct (G, VVS1)

2nd Pic:
C de Cartier (PG .50ct) vs. 1895 (YG .50ct G, VVS1)

The 1 carat looked too huge for everyday to me so I’m not considering that one at all.

I plan to get the .50ct size when I decide on one of these necklaces; however, I can’t decide if I prefer the C de Cartier style or the 1895 style.

I like the weight of the C design, the boldness of the design as well as how it makes the diamond look square and more substantial; whereas, I also like the 1895 as it is a timeless design, looks daintier and makes the diamond appear like it’s floating. I think I’m leaning toward the 1895 necklace.

My husband prefers the 1895 design and states the YG looks better on me, and I agree as I like YG for earrings and necklaces while I like RG for my bracelets and rings at the moment.

 

[Tolstoi123]

Today I tried on the C de Cartier Diamond Necklace as well as the 1895 Necklace.

1st Pic: C de Cartier
Both PG size .30ct (G, VS1) and .50ct (G, VVS1)

2nd Pic:
C de Cartier (PG .50ct) vs. 1895 (YG .50ct G, VVS1)

The 1 carat looked too huge for everyday to me so I’m not considering that one at all.

I plan to get the .50ct size when I decide on one of these necklaces; however, I can’t decide if I prefer the C de Cartier style or the 1895 style.

I like the weight of the C design, the boldness of the design as well as how it makes the diamond look square and more substantial; whereas, I also like the 1895 as it is a timeless design, looks daintier and makes the diamond appear like it’s floating. I think I’m leaning toward the 1895 necklace.

My husband prefers the 1895 design and states the YG looks better on me, and I agree as I like YG for earrings and necklaces while I like RG for my bracelets and rings at the moment.

View attachment 4916020

View attachment 4916021

I feel the 1895 is more classic and elegant whereas the C is more of a statement! I strongly prefer the 1895 but I am clearly biased since I own one myself . It looks more refined IMO and yes I like the floating diamond effect!
It looks gorgeous on you.

 

[Tolstoi123]

Thank you both for the advice! I think that you’re right — she is not going to be unhappy about the larger diamond, especially since it’s still relatively dainty/small. Now I just need to make an appointment at one of the nearby Cartier locations. After reading about some of the experiences that people have had ordering online, it seems better to go in store...or at least order from the store over the phone.

Agreed with the above comments! Since both diamond are small it remains very dainty and honestly there is not a world of difference between the two. I tried both on a few months ago, here are some not so great pictures but it gives an idea of the proportions.

 

[xsimplicity]

Today I tried on the C de Cartier Diamond Necklace as well as the 1895 Necklace.

1st Pic: C de Cartier
Both PG size .30ct (G, VS1) and .50ct (G, VVS1)

2nd Pic:
C de Cartier (PG .50ct) vs. 1895 (YG .50ct G, VVS1)

The 1 carat looked too huge for everyday to me so I’m not considering that one at all.

I plan to get the .50ct size when I decide on one of these necklaces; however, I can’t decide if I prefer the C de Cartier style or the 1895 style.

I like the weight of the C design, the boldness of the design as well as how it makes the diamond look square and more substantial; whereas, I also like the 1895 as it is a timeless design, looks daintier and makes the diamond appear like it’s floating. I think I’m leaning toward the 1895 necklace.

My husband prefers the 1895 design and states the YG looks better on me, and I agree as I like YG for earrings and necklaces while I like RG for my bracelets and rings at the moment.

Thanks for this comparison picture! I recently fell in love with the C De Cartier necklace and have been itching to get one. Only problem is that I don’t live close to a boutique to try on the sizes. It’s hard to gauge from pictures without actually trying it on. My SA showed me a picture of 0.59 vs 1.02 carat and I’m definitely leaning towards the 0.59. We’re doing a video chat in a few days so hopefully I can make a decision then.

 

[Chaton]

Thanks for this comparison picture! I recently fell in love with the C De Cartier necklace and have been itching to get one. Only problem is that I don’t live close to a boutique to try on the sizes. It’s hard to gauge from pictures without actually trying it on. My SA showed me a picture of 0.59 vs 1.02 carat and I’m definitely leaning towards the 0.59. We’re doing a video chat in a few days so hopefully I can make a decision then.

You are welcome. Honestly, I think the 1 carat is a bit too huge especially in the C de Cartier design, which I think makes the diamond look sooo much bigger, even the .30 carat looks really nice and substantial in my opinion due to the thick gold setting surrounding the diamond. Having said that, how can anyone go wrong with a bigger diamond size, right? We can all MAKE IT WORK! LOL

Let us know what you decide. The C de Cartier setting is GORGEOUS!

 

[xsimplicity]

You are welcome. Honestly, I think the 1 carat is a bit too huge especially in the C de Cartier design, which I think makes the diamond look sooo much bigger, even the .30 carat looks really nice and substantial in my opinion due to the thick gold setting surrounding the diamond. Having said that, how can anyone go wrong with a bigger diamond size, right? We can all MAKE IT WORK! LOL

Let us know what you decide. The C de Cartier setting is GORGEOUS!

After seeing the 1 carat, I knew it was too big for me. So I started contemplating 0.3 and 0.5, which is why I so appreciate your picture!

For anyone who wants eye candy, here’s the 0.59 vs 1.02 carat.

 

[Chaton]

I agree. It's one of those times where less is more. It's almost too much as the setting has to be bigger, and then I just think it takes away from the whole diamond and delicate setting - like almost too BOLD!

When I tried them on, I love the delicateness of the .30 ct to be honest, but I thought I could go a little bigger and that's why I am considering the .50 ct.

Btw, I have done a little bit of research on diamond color and settings that may help you narrow your selection or carat size. When diamonds are set in YG/RG the diamond can get away with being a lower color than when set in WG because any yellow in the diamond will be more visible in white settings. Therefore, being that it is set in RG, the diamond color has an advantage as even if it is a lesser grade, you can get away with it because the novice eye will not notice it. Moreover, when a diamond is in a setting, even gemologists will get the color 1 grade off unless the diamond is free standing.

 

[xsimplicity]

I agree. It's one of those times where less is more. It's almost too much as the setting has to be bigger, and then I just think it takes away from the whole diamond and delicate setting - like almost too BOLD!

When I tried them on, I love the delicateness of the .30 ct to be honest, but I thought I could go a little bigger and that's why I am considering the .50 ct.

Btw, I have done a little bit of research on diamond color and settings that may help you narrow your selection or carat size. When diamonds are set in YG/RG the diamond can get away with being a lower color than when set in WG because any yellow in the diamond will be more visible in white settings. Therefore, being that it is set in RG, the diamond color has an advantage as even if it is a lesser grade, you can get away with it because the novice eye will not notice it. Moreover, when a diamond is in a setting, even gemologists will get the color 1 grade off unless the diamond is free standing.

We must be of like minds because I was researching diamonds tonight too! I definitely want it to be RG. And I’m thinking at least G color. If I’m going to be paying a good amount of money for this, I’d prefer a good quality diamond.