Legacy satchel in whiskey or black?

[Munchkyn]

I have a legacy shoulder bag in natural now and I want the satchel but can't decide which color. I love the whiskey color but is it too close to the natural color? I like the black b/c it seems to make the hardware pop on the satchel.

I just can't decide, I like them both

 

[ktdid]

I have the whiskey satchel so that's my vote. However, if I *worked* at Coach, I'd buy one of each

 

[LizCordova]

The whiskey color is not too close to the natural. You could also get the pond. Good luck deciding. I just got the Mandy in the Natural and love it!

 

[jewelebeanie]

Out of your choices, I'd go with whiskey. Personally, I really want the satchel in brown for autumn.

 

[tigerdrago28]

I like the whiskey as well.

 

[Kiari]

I like Whiskey but think it is too close to natural so I would go with the black.

I really like how the hardware stands out on the black.

 

[kathyrose]

Love both but would go with the black.

 

[ranskimmie]

Hey Munchkyn! I voted black. The whiskey is o.k. buy the black is TDF! So would that be legacy......ali,........shoulder,........mandy??? Do tell

 

[upswife]

Whiskey all the way baby!

 

[randarific]

I have - and love - the black. It's very versatile.

 

[razorbackbelle0]

LOL 50/50 on the poll, we aren't helping at all, are we?

 

[Munchkyn]

^^^Ahh, nope! So hard...
I am usually a brown shade kinda gal and have clothes with earth tones so I know for sure the whiskey would look great with everything I have. But I don't really have a black bag but then again the whiskey is so gorgeous. Does anyone have pics of them holding either color?