Lady Dior, Hermes Picotin, YSL Sac de Jour, Chanel Boy, or Chanel Classic Flap?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Good choices. I would carefully check out both before making a final decision

Yes, that's a good idea... I am definitely going to the boutiques before I make my final decision :yes:

I only have Chanel and Lady Dior of the bags you are considering and I am considering SDJ as a work bag.
Dior still is not that common to be seen but it is very difficult to compare Dior and Chanel Flap cause they just are so different, quilted/cannage.
SDJ and Picotin are the most descrete and work apropriate
Flap, Boy and LD are to be seen classics.
You perhaps need something for work and something classic for fun?
Nice pics from AverageJoe and personally love my LD even little more than Chanel.

Thanks for the response... right now I'm leaning towards the LD and the classic flap :smile1:


I like the Chanel flap and the SDJ.

The Chanel flap is a timeless piece and, in my opinion, it's something every bag lover has to own.
The SDJ is more causual but I love the design.

The Picotin isn't really my style and it isn't something I'd ever consider buying. The Dior is a classic piece but I feel it's something someone older (over 60) would wear. The Chanel Boy is very trendy now but not as timeless as the classic flap.

I like the sdj, but I don't own any of these so pay no attention to me. :p

(I'm not really into larger patterns/textures.)

Thank you Eva and Jesssh for your much valued input!

Many people say that the Lady Dior is dressy and everything, but it's a matter of how you style it. Just like the Chanel Classic Flap can look very evening-like and dressy while going perfectly with a pair of jeans, the Lady Dior can do the same.

I have attached some pictures of Emmy Rossum, Sarah Hyland, and Miranda Kerr with their Lady Dior bags worn casually, just to show you some different styling pictures.

For the price of a used Chanel in good condition, you can get a brand new Lady Dior from the boutique with warranty and the full customer service experience :smile1:

I love these pictures! Thank you for sharing!


You're welcome, SeleneMarta! I also enjoyed reading the responses here.

I would really recommend going to a Chanel boutique (or department store that sells Chanel) to try the different sizes of the flap bags (M/L, Jumbo and hopefully 226 and 227 if you're interested in the reissues) and feel the leathers (caviar, lamb, distressed calfskin).

This way, you can determine what is best for you and your lifestyle. There are many caviar lovers, many lamb lovers and also distressed calf reissue lovers and it wouldn't be fair to pick one without at least experiencing them all. With Chanel, I bought and returned caviar and patent bags until I realized that lamb and distressed calfskin were what I really loved.

The classic flaps and reissues hold their value very well, so sometimes you won't see a big difference in price between new and gently preloved. I'm sure you already know to be aware of fakes, so I won't discuss those risks here. Personally, I would buy new unless I was buying from someone I know has only authentic bags or from a reputable consigner like Yoogi's or AFF. But really, if the price difference between new and preloved is only like 10%, it's worth just buying new.

Regarding caviar vs. lambskin, there are many discussions on the Chanel forum on that topic, but my two cents is that lamb isn't as delicate as some think it is and if repairs are needed, you can repair lambskin to make it look good again, but you cannot replicate the texture when you repair caviar. I think you should just buy what leather you love, not sacrifice your decision because of perceived durability. :smile1:

Thank you again for another very informative and helpful response! I will be trying out the bags in the boutiques before I buy, and I will get what I fall in love with :smile1:
 
Many people say that the Lady Dior is dressy and everything, but it's a matter of how you style it. Just like the Chanel Classic Flap can look very evening-like and dressy while going perfectly with a pair of jeans, the Lady Dior can do the same.



I have attached some pictures of Emmy Rossum, Sarah Hyland, and Miranda Kerr with their Lady Dior bags worn casually, just to show you some different styling pictures.



For the price of a used Chanel in good condition, you can get a brand new Lady Dior from the boutique with warranty and the full customer service experience :smile1:


You've sold me averagejoe!!
 
Personally, I don't see the appeal in the YSL Sac de Jour at all. In my opinion, it doesn't even hold a candle to the other bags you're considering.

I'd say go for the Chanel flap. It's classic. If you're worried about quality, perhaps get a pre-owned bag that's in excellent condition.

Please don't get the Sac de Jour when you could be getting a Chanel flap! Don't break my heart ;)
 
Hi,
I own the Sac de Jour (grained leather) and would highly recommend it. This bag is gorgeous and very well made. It's one of my all time favorite bags. Very classy!
I'm saving for a Chanel flap and can't wait to get this bag someday - same with a Lady Dior.
These three bags are kind of versatile since you can handheld it or carry it as a shoulder bag. Put that into consideration. The H. Picotin would be a no-go for me since you cannot wear ir on your shoulder.
If you go for Hermes, I recommend chosing a more iconic design (or an Hermes market bucket bag).
The Chanel classic flap is way more timeless than the the boy bag.
Not that much of a help, I guess? ;-)

Best, cherrybelly
 
Many people say that the Lady Dior is dressy and everything, but it's a matter of how you style it. Just like the Chanel Classic Flap can look very evening-like and dressy while going perfectly with a pair of jeans, the Lady Dior can do the same.

I have attached some pictures of Emmy Rossum, Sarah Hyland, and Miranda Kerr with their Lady Dior bags worn casually, just to show you some different styling pictures.

For the price of a used Chanel in good condition, you can get a brand new Lady Dior from the boutique with warranty and the full customer service experience :smile1:

Hi averagejoe, do you know what size LD these ladies are carrying? You have impeccable taste and this bag has caught my attention!
 
I found this thread at the perfect time! I'm also currently debating on whether to get a lady dior, SDJ, or valentino tote and its great reading everyone's opinion...dilemma..dilemma..;)

So I already own the chanel flap and boy and to be honest I don't find too many occasions to wear them since I'm super casual (jeans and flats everyday...) and find them too "dressy". The boy is also a tad too structured for me and sticks out if I carry it the long way and feels awkward when I shoulder carry it. But I bought mine when they were cheaper and it shocks me to see that prices have jumped so fast so quickly! So if you consider their resale value if you ever decide to sell them...

The SDJ I feel is super cute but is heavy and seems very structured too so not sure how I feel about that one...It would double as a great work bag though.

Lady Dior is beautiful whether being carried by hand or by the strap. I've never held one in my hands, but I've seen many on the streets and I feel it is truly a dior classic ;)

Good luck!!
I hope you'll decide on a bag soon!!
 
I found this thread at the perfect time! I'm also currently debating on whether to get a lady dior, SDJ, or valentino tote and its great reading everyone's opinion...dilemma..dilemma..;)

So I already own the chanel flap and boy and to be honest I don't find too many occasions to wear them since I'm super casual (jeans and flats everyday...) and find them too "dressy". The boy is also a tad too structured for me and sticks out if I carry it the long way and feels awkward when I shoulder carry it. But I bought mine when they were cheaper and it shocks me to see that prices have jumped so fast so quickly! So if you consider their resale value if you ever decide to sell them...

The SDJ I feel is super cute but is heavy and seems very structured too so not sure how I feel about that one...It would double as a great work bag though.

Lady Dior is beautiful whether being carried by hand or by the strap. I've never held one in my hands, but I've seen many on the streets and I feel it is truly a dior classic ;)

Good luck!!
I hope you'll decide on a bag soon!!
Hi scbabe,
as I said: I own the Saint Laurent SdJ in grained leather and love this bag. It's sophisticated but at the same time a great everyday bag.
Valentino is great too. What do you think about the glam lock flap bag?
Yesterday I tried the Lady Dior (small size) in the Dior boutique - and I was disappointed 'cause this one looked like a dated old lady's purse (is it the quilting, the shape or the handles, maybe the charms? - I don't know). Don't want to offend anyone, but that's how I felt when I was wearing it in the boutique. No Lady Dior for me. :-(
I better invest in a Chanel Jumbo flap...

Best,
cherrybelly
 
Top