TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
i've never liked the martini setting myself.
To add some input...the store I shop no longer carries basket set diamond earrings. ( I felt ancient) They also do not carry any total weight diamond earrings larger that 2.0 carats. They are a higher end jewelry store and apparently once you get to this size earring the buying power for this quality level is just not there (at this price point).
She told me once you go over the two carat size it then becomes a larger cost differential and they begin to see customers that want to set the stones in basket settings. She stated the basket setting is still the most secure for the larger stones. She also stated you can have the post made to accommodate the larger elephant back to keep the earring from drooping. It all comes down to what you love.