Is a Cartier watch more “quiet luxury” than a Rolex?

[GoldenGlitter]

Even in gold and with diamonds, the cartier panthere watch still seems less of a target, if that makes sense. But is this a misconception? I know there are different opinions on the whole “quiet luxury” concept. In this case, I mean something less likely to be recognized or spotted as a luxury or designer item, but still looks like fine craftsmanship Please tell me your own opinions!

 

[circemedusa]

I would say so but it really depends on the watch itself. Overall, I find Cartier watches to be more elegant and versatile while Rolex to me leans much more sporty/“cool” looking if that makes sense.

 

[Swanky]

No not imo. Both are high profile brands to me.

 

[NLVOEWITHLV]

No. I just think that Rolex is more recognizable to the layman that isn’t into luxury brands.

 

[MinimalStyle]

I don’t think any qualifies for ‘quiet luxury’ but possibly Cartier is less ‘in your face’ depends on the model. Just my opinion.

 

[San Diego Julie]

I think Rolex is more recognizable to people than Cartier.. I googled brand awareness and Rolex is 87% in the US, while Cartier is only 70%.

 

[sdkitty]

if rolex is SS without diamonds, I don't think it's that noticeable to the average person

 

[NLVOEWITHLV]

if rolex is SS without diamonds, I don't think it's that noticeable to the average person

On the contrary, ss with fluted bezel is one of the most popular models. My ss fluted bezel is more noticed and complimented than any other watch I own!

 

[sdkitty]

On the contrary, ss with fluted bezel is one of the most popular models. My ss fluted bezel is more noticed and complimented than any other watch I own!

I don't have a fluted bezel on my watch and it doesn't get noticed much which is fine with me I don't want to be mugged for my jewelry

 

[NLVOEWITHLV]

I don't have a fluted bezel on my watch and it doesn't get noticed much which is fine with me I don't want to be mugged for my jewelry

Oh ok, so your ss Rolex may go unnoticed, just like the Rolex models without the cyclops I think would also be more under the radar. However, if the ss Rolex has the configurations that many see as iconic to the brand it will draw attention. For example fluted bezel, jubilee bracelet, cyclops etc.

 

[sdkitty]

Oh ok, so your ss Rolex may go unnoticed, just like the Rolex models without the cyclops I think would also be more under the radar. However, if the ss Rolex has the configurations that many see as iconic to the brand it will draw attention. For example fluted bezel, jubilee bracelet, cyclops etc.

it also depends on who you are around. some people have complimented me on my watch.

 

[sgj99]

I definitely think Cartier is the more “quiet luxury” watch.

 

[Pop Art Suzy]

Oh ok, so your ss Rolex may go unnoticed, just like the Rolex models without the cyclops I think would also be more under the radar. However, if the ss Rolex has the configurations that many see as iconic to the brand it will draw attention. For example fluted bezel, jubilee bracelet, cyclops etc.

Sounds exactly like mine lol.

 

[Pop Art Suzy]

I've always loved Cartier watches, especially the Pasha (for men, because I prefer larger watches). I'm contemplating selling my Rolex to get a Cartier watch, but I don't know yet. Still debating. I also love the Quartz movement, too.

 

[jellyv]

OP I'm confused by your term "target," which implies interest in avoiding theft. Is that what you mean to ask about? Or do you mean, less likely to be a target of random attention? Anyone into luxury goods recognizes Cartier, thieves included.

I definitely think the Cartier Panthere watch case looks just like a classic Cartier, hence luxury, just as most Rolex models (Sub, DateJust) are highly recognizable. Plenty of people know bupkis about either brand.

Buy what you love!