I would always go with the larger size, as most people's wrists swelling during the summer. Not to mention, no one likes to think about it, but if you put on some weight over the years, the smaller size is going to become rather tight and may be uncomfortable.
What?! I'd just sell it off because it's obviously no longer doing the job it's supposed to do.
Like my car, my last boyfriend...etc.
"Leave the bracelet, take the cannoli"