Don't buy a bag if you hate the color. I agree with the poster above, just wait until you find one that works. It might even be that you find the Celine in a color you prefer.
Help! YSL, Celine or Coach?!
- Thread starter Ladan Mrss
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
The Coach Rogue is a very well made bag. The Leather, the hardware, suede lining in the two outer most pockets. I own one. Or a few. I don't think you would be sorry for your decision.
As you are in the UAE, have a look at lya lya bags..
I was taking some fresh air outside the Dubai Mall when I saw a lady carrying a bag I fell in love with.
The lady happened to be a famous blogger in the Middle East.
She told me it was the Vultura from Lya Lya....
They have a website and their bags can be found in Abu Dhabi....
www.lya-lya.com
Congratulations on getting control of your depression. Stay strong.Lovelies:
In celebration or finally being happy and having my depression under control, I'm planning to treat myself to a new handbag. I work full time, spend most of the day out and head to the gym right after I leave the office. I'm in love with colors and never settle down for black (I actually do not have a black bag). My favorite bag is my lovely Proenza Schouler PS1 in Royal blue. I'm petite and short and inexperienced with structured bags as I parted away with my Prada Lux tote shortly after I got it (was too boxy) and I still cannot force myself in using my Cambridge Satchel for the same reason.
Now with specific budget in mind, I have finalized the followings:
1. Coach Rogue - Steel Blue (Brand new)
2. Celine Luggage Tote - Dune (Preloved)
3. YSL Sac de jour - Burgundy (Preloved)
4. YSL Sac de jour - Nano size, Royal Blue (Preloved)
I love love love the celine but I don't know how I feel about the color and I have made the mistake of buying a bag because I l loved the design but hated the color and now its sitting in my closet. I have no idea what to think about the YSL ones, I love their classic look but I'm just not sure, on the other hand, I do not know how stiff and structured it can be. I love everything about Coach, it's just that I never ever considered buying a bag from this brand and with the new designer team and all the changes, I've found myself quite liking it. It is the price that really makes me consider other options as I can purchase designer brands (although preloved) but high end nonetheless with the same amount.
Let me know what you think? Thank you in advance.
View attachment 3750811
Since you already have a PS1 in royal blue, I would eliminate the nano in the same color (unless it's your favorite color).
I'm leaning towards the dune Celine first then Coach rogue second.
Since you don't seem to like structured bags, the Sac du Jour and lugga tote should be off the list for sure.
The Rouge is nice but I found it to be heavy - and the color is not ideal. I like the smaller one a little more and it is not too heavy. It is a softer leather so not too structured. I concur with the poster above - it is a lot nicer than many bags 2-3x its price.
I think you should also consider the Celine Belt bag.
The Rouge is nice but I found it to be heavy - and the color is not ideal. I like the smaller one a little more and it is not too heavy. It is a softer leather so not too structured. I concur with the poster above - it is a lot nicer than many bags 2-3x its price.
I think you should also consider the Celine Belt bag.
The Celine gets my vote, but I would wait for a color you love. Don't settle!
Ah, you have indeed made your decision - get that blue YSL Nano. 
As others have noted, the Coach is very heavy, even unloaded.
On a side note: I have always loved the medium PS/1 but can't enjoy because of that slouchiness that you enjoy. It is a beautiful design! I will continue to live vicariously through you!
As others have noted, the Coach is very heavy, even unloaded.
On a side note: I have always loved the medium PS/1 but can't enjoy because of that slouchiness that you enjoy. It is a beautiful design! I will continue to live vicariously through you!
I truly appreciate your efforts and replies
It is very refreshing how I can talk about bags and not get "rolling eyes" in return 
so THANK YOU
I visited one of the main shopping malls that have all the designers under one roof and came back home even more confused. My first stop was Celine, I wanted to see the color Dune in person and was pleasantly surprised to find out that it has a very rich grey undertone, almost khaki? hard to explain but very very lovely. The problem is that the seller is not aware of the color and she said "off white"...don't know what that means? help?! I love this designer but the micro size was always the one I would dream about, the nano size was simple and beautiful, with a very long shoulder strap. I liked it, it's safe.
I went to Harvey Nichols next (used to worked here_UK_ when I was a Uni student
). Stopped by Balenciaga and the mini city bags to my horror looked absolutely hideous ob my body. Tried the Coach Rogue again, unfortunately the SA had already left!! and I couldn't ask for the Olive one. Beautiful but not enough to justify the price, not for Coach, IN MY OPINION, don't kill me 
. I just feel the smaller size does not feel right on my body, does not come with cross-body strap and yes I know I can attach them together but wouldn't that be painful? The medium size jut too big for me as a formal, classic, dainty and business meeting time worthy bag and small does not sparkle. I really really wish they would have the suede lining for the zipper compartment, hate the fabric.
I checked Gucci, Lya Lya, Alexander Mcqueen (liked the mini Heroine ones, so cute) and Givenchy (some other time maybe) and finally headed over Saint Laurent. I absolutely loved everything aboud Sac de Jour, tried Nano, Baby and Small and liked them all the same. The Nano was similar to Gucci soho, Celine Nano Luggage and I want to say bigger and definitely more spacious than YSL Blogger bag. The small size is definitly a medium/large quite similar to Prada Lux Tote but lighter and less structured due to round corners.
So, I think I will go for YSL SDJ nano in royal blue with gold hardware, but I would be trilled to read your suggestions and comments.
It is very refreshing how I can talk about bags and not get "rolling eyes" in return so THANK YOUI visited one of the main shopping malls that have all the designers under one roof and came back home even more confused. My first stop was Celine, I wanted to see the color Dune in person and was pleasantly surprised to find out that it has a very rich grey undertone, almost khaki? hard to explain but very very lovely. The problem is that the seller is not aware of the color and she said "off white"...don't know what that means? help?! I love this designer but the micro size was always the one I would dream about, the nano size was simple and beautiful, with a very long shoulder strap. I liked it, it's safe.
I went to Harvey Nichols next (used to worked here_UK_ when I was a Uni student
). Stopped by Balenciaga and the mini city bags to my horror looked absolutely hideous ob my body. Tried the Coach Rogue again, unfortunately the SA had already left!! and I couldn't ask for the Olive one. Beautiful but not enough to justify the price, not for Coach, IN MY OPINION, don't kill me . I just feel the smaller size does not feel right on my body, does not come with cross-body strap and yes I know I can attach them together but wouldn't that be painful? The medium size jut too big for me as a formal, classic, dainty and business meeting time worthy bag and small does not sparkle. I really really wish they would have the suede lining for the zipper compartment, hate the fabric. I checked Gucci, Lya Lya, Alexander Mcqueen (liked the mini Heroine ones, so cute) and Givenchy (some other time maybe) and finally headed over Saint Laurent. I absolutely loved everything aboud Sac de Jour, tried Nano, Baby and Small and liked them all the same. The Nano was similar to Gucci soho, Celine Nano Luggage and I want to say bigger and definitely more spacious than YSL Blogger bag. The small size is definitly a medium/large quite similar to Prada Lux Tote but lighter and less structured due to round corners.
So, I think I will go for YSL SDJ nano in royal blue with gold hardware, but I would be trilled to read your suggestions and comments.
I think the sac du jour is a great bag, but since you mentioned you don't like structured bags - think long and hard about it. It is definitely super structured. My 2 cents. I'd hate for you to invest and not use it enough.
I know I have purchased bags that looked awesome but I did not find practical enough to use and they end up collecting dust. So I am definitely a lot more specific. I know that a super structured bag is all wrong for my life right now, and while I love the sac du jour it isn't a good fit (although at this point the souple is probably perfect for me. Lol. I am tempted. That is loosened up enough to fit for me.)
I know I have purchased bags that looked awesome but I did not find practical enough to use and they end up collecting dust. So I am definitely a lot more specific. I know that a super structured bag is all wrong for my life right now, and while I love the sac du jour it isn't a good fit (although at this point the souple is probably perfect for me. Lol. I am tempted. That is loosened up enough to fit for me.)
Good job Ladan Mrss!I truly appreciate your efforts and replies
I visited one of the main shopping malls that have all the designers under one roof and came back home even more confused. My first stop was Celine, I wanted to see the color Dune in person and was pleasantly surprised to find out that it has a very rich grey undertone, almost khaki? hard to explain but very very lovely. The problem is that the seller is not aware of the color and she said "off white"...don't know what that means? help?! I love this designer but the micro size was always the one I would dream about, the nano size was simple and beautiful, with a very long shoulder strap. I liked it, it's safe.
I went to Harvey Nichols next (used to worked here_UK_ when I was a Uni student
I checked Gucci, Lya Lya, Alexander Mcqueen (liked the mini Heroine ones, so cute) and Givenchy (some other time maybe) and finally headed over Saint Laurent. I absolutely loved everything aboud Sac de Jour, tried Nano, Baby and Small and liked them all the same. The Nano was similar to Gucci soho, Celine Nano Luggage and I want to say bigger and definitely more spacious than YSL Blogger bag. The small size is definitly a medium/large quite similar to Prada Lux Tote but lighter and less structured due to round corners.
So, I think I will go for YSL SDJ nano in royal blue with gold hardware, but I would be trilled to read your suggestions and comments.
It's always better to see the bags in real life.
Seems that the SDJ was your first love...
Keep us posted!
