I went through a similar decision when I decided to get a small JUC ring for my right hand. I wear mostly white gold/silver, with some rose gold mixed in and seldom wear yellow gold (I own only a few pieces of yellow gold jewelry, none are luxury pieces). I was trying to decide whether to get the ring in either WG or RG. I felt that sometimes I get bored with white metals and decided I wanted the Cartier ring to pop against my other pieces so I purchased the RG. I love the ring so much!! I did not have a store in Colorado to try on pieces or maybe I would have been swayed more one way or another. I ordered online but the pieces are so pretty in all metals that you can’t go wrong. In my opinion both metals look great on your skin tone. I say go with what makes your heart and eyes happy .