Help needed to pick out diamond studs!

[sneezz]

Thanks again everyone! Gonna get #1!

 

[sneezz]

Oh dear, I didn't do all my research and these diamonds score above 3 using the HCA tool on pricescope. Should I be worried? The rep over at whiteflash said that since the crown angle is at 36, there'd be a halo effect seen in the diamond.???

Now I'm looking at the whiteflash ACAs. ush:

 

[Cara Mia]

Id go w/ #3- just my opinion, but Id never buy anything under vs2, earrings or not.

 

[mrs moulds]

#3

 

[lovely_bag]

#1, hands down.

Hi ame!

you said #1 - is it because the table is smaller?
Or the thin-med faceted girdle?
I would love to understand which criteria matters, when Colour, Clarity and Carat are the same.

Thank you!

 

[ame]

Table size, depth AND the thinner girdle. The medium to thick means that more of the weight is in the girdle.