Help! Cartier necklace, Pomellato or Tiffany rings?

[Monaliceke]

Here's a picture, it's a real statement ring

Wow! That's indeed very pretty! Thanks for sharing.

 

[Monaliceke]

My vote is definitely for the Nudo ring--I absolutely love the combination of London blue topaz and amethyst. Gorgeous! My second choice would be for the other Pomellato ring, it is stunning. The Cartier pendant might be nice for everyday wear but it is quite small, when I saw it in person I was surprised at just how dainty it is.

I am always a sucker for deep color so I can't help voting for that, it is always so lovely to see on a lady's hand! Good luck with your decision and have a wonderful birthday!

+1
I also have two nudos stacked, London blue topaz and the light blue topaz stone, I find it super comfortable and wear it daily.

Thanks sailorstripes and Myke518 for your valuable feedback.

May I ask if Myke518 could share a picture of you wearing your nudos stacked? Thank you in advance.

 

[Monaliceke]

Thanks for all your feedback. Hmmmm, looks like the rings are getting the most votes.

 

[couturequeen]

Nudo! I think the design is much more classic than the other options. For that amount of money, I'd go with something that will work over the years.

 

[Myke518]

Thanks sailorstripes and Myke518 for your valuable feedback.

May I ask if Myke518 could share a picture of you wearing your nudos stacked? Thank you in advance.

Of course. Here you go-- apologies for the weird angle, I wanted to hide my dire need for a manicure situation

 

[arwen]

arwen, may I ask you to post a picture of you wearing your Nudos stacked please? Thanks a lot!

Here they are- please excuse my messy hands....winter time and my two cats always make them look dry and scratched :shame:

 

[Monaliceke]

Here they are- please excuse my messy hands....winter time and my two cats always make them look dry and scratched :shame:

Wow, what gemstones are these? They are so beautiful together! I believe these colors can be worn all year round, isn't it? Good choice! Thanks for sharing.

 

[Monaliceke]

Of course. Here you go-- apologies for the weird angle, I wanted to hide my dire need for a manicure situation View attachment 2929318

Wow, you have the Maxi London Blue Topaz and the medium size Blue Topaz nudos stacked. Gorgeous! I have the London Blue Topaz too, but in medium size. Looks like I will have to try on the maxi to see how it looks on me Thanks so much for sharing.

 

[Monaliceke]

Nudo! I think the design is much more classic than the other options. For that amount of money, I'd go with something that will work over the years.

Yes, you're right. I need something versatile that I can wear very often and which will be an evergreen piece of jewel. Thanks.

 

[Melora24]

DH have kindly offered to get me something special for my birthday and he wants to know what's on my wish list. I am hesitating as I have a few items on my mind.

Would love your feedback on these items:

1. Amulette de Cartier - small pendant / chain either in MOP or Onyx

2. Pomellato Amethyst Nudo (regular size) --> to stack with my Nudo London Blue Topaz which DH bought for my birthday 5 years ago. I have seen many photos on stacking Nudos and they're pretty, just not sure if it would be comfy.

3. Pomellato M'ama non M'ama Amethyst and Tsavorites ring

4. Tiffany Sparklers Amethyst ring

I attached the pictures for ref. Thanks in advance!

This may be a weird question, but why don't you give him this list? If you have a hard time deciding between them, it's because you love them all.
And if he chooses himself, then it'll have more meaning, won't it?

That what we did for my push gift: I visited almost a dozen jewellers, came back with a list, and only discovered what he got me after our child was born I loved the element of surprise.

 

[arwen]

Wow, what gemstones are these? They are so beautiful together! I believe these colors can be worn all year round, isn't it? Good choice! Thanks for sharing.

Thanks These are the Rose de France and the Prasiolith. Yes, they are very versatile and I wear them all year round.
If I ever get a 3rd I am contemplating between the London Blue Topaz and the lighter Blue Topaz.

 

[Monaliceke]

This may be a weird question, but why don't you give him this list? If you have a hard time deciding between them, it's because you love them all.
And if he chooses himself, then it'll have more meaning, won't it?

That what we did for my push gift: I visited almost a dozen jewellers, came back with a list, and only discovered what he got me after our child was born I loved the element of surprise.

That's a good idea. So I should first go check out the items personally, then give him the list. Yes! Thanks.

 

[Monaliceke]

Thanks These are the Rose de France and the Prasiolith. Yes, they are very versatile and I wear them all year round.
If I ever get a 3rd I am contemplating between the London Blue Topaz and the lighter Blue Topaz.

I love the pinkish/lilac color of the Rose de France. I think it would pair well with the blue Topaz. I will give it a try when I visit Pomellato.

 

[amateurjeweler]

The sparkler definitely seems more "worth it" to me than the nudo - what a large pop of color! The nudos look great too, particularly Arwen's amazing earth-tone stack.

I voted for the Amulette though. I feel it's the most timeless option here. The nudo rings throw off a gentrified boho vibe and the sparkler demands an elegant ensemble. I think you could wear the smaller onyx Amulette 24/7.

 

[pinkkitty2011]

The amethyst ring is gorgeous 😍👌❤️