Help! Cartier necklace, Pomellato or Tiffany rings?

Cartier, Pomellato Nudo / M'ama non M'ama or Tiffany Sparkler

  • Amulette de Cartier small pendant-chain in MOP / Onyx

  • Pomellato Amethyst Nudo - regular size (Medium)

  • Pomellato Amethyst-Tsavorites M'ama non M'ama

  • Tiffany Amethyst Sparklers

Results are only viewable after voting.

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Monaliceke

Monaliceke

O.G.
Jun 28, 2007
1,274
838
#1
DH have kindly offered to get me something special for my birthday and he wants to know what's on my wish list. I am hesitating as I have a few items on my mind.

Would love your feedback on these items:

1. Amulette de Cartier - small pendant / chain either in MOP or Onyx

2. Pomellato Amethyst Nudo (regular size) --> to stack with my Nudo London Blue Topaz which DH bought for my birthday 5 years ago. I have seen many photos on stacking Nudos and they're pretty, just not sure if it would be comfy.

3. Pomellato M'ama non M'ama Amethyst and Tsavorites ring

4. Tiffany Sparklers Amethyst ring

I attached the pictures for ref. Thanks in advance!
 

Attachments

  • 1 Amulette de Cartier.png
    1 Amulette de Cartier.png
    58.2 KB · Views: 1,280
  • 2 Pomellato Amethyst Nudo.png
    2 Pomellato Amethyst Nudo.png
    82.7 KB · Views: 1,368
  • 3 Pomellato Amethyst-Tsavorites.png
    3 Pomellato Amethyst-Tsavorites.png
    84.2 KB · Views: 1,292
  • 4 Tiffany Amethyst Sparklers.png
    4 Tiffany Amethyst Sparklers.png
    413.5 KB · Views: 1,267
#4
Very nice choices! And happy upcoming birthday! [emoji512]. Based on your selections, are you leaning more towards a ring? I think they are all beautiful, but I would probably get other one of the undo rings. They are very pretty and stacking could be fun. I love the cartier pendant, and like Rami, I love it in mop. Do you have more pendants or rings? Which do you feel is missing more in your current collection?
 
#5
Oh wow, nice but tough choices.

Do you wear your Nudo often? I have 2 Nudos and always wear them stacked. One looks a bit lost and they are really comfy to wear (and I have small hands and fingers).

If so, go for the 2nd Nudo.

My secondy choice would be the Cartier necklace, not so much a fan of the Amulette collection, but it is a design you can wear daily and I agree, it looks sophisticated.

Maybe it is helpful to think what you would wear more often/what would be more versatile.
 
#6
Thanks Rami00, LovEmAll and arwen for your feedback.

Yes, I wear my Nudo ring often, but it's a bit loose on my finger. They didn't really have the right fit for my ring finger -- meaning if I go for 1 size smaller, it's too tight & would have problem putting on during summer. The SA suggested then already that I should have 2 nudos stacked together to make it slightly more fitting.

I agree that the Cartier Amulette necklace would be a good choice since I would probably get to wear it more often than the rings. However, since I live in Belgium, it's mostly cool/cold here and I'm not sure if the necklace would look too dainty with pullovers / jackets / cardigans year round.
I really like the style though.

arwen, may I ask you to post a picture of you wearing your Nudos stacked please? Thanks a lot!

I hope to get more feedback from other TPF members too before I make my choice.
 
#8
My vote is definitely for the Nudo ring--I absolutely love the combination of London blue topaz and amethyst. Gorgeous! My second choice would be for the other Pomellato ring, it is stunning. The Cartier pendant might be nice for everyday wear but it is quite small, when I saw it in person I was surprised at just how dainty it is.

I am always a sucker for deep color so I can't help voting for that, it is always so lovely to see on a lady's hand! Good luck with your decision and have a wonderful birthday!
 
#9
sailorstripes said:
My vote is definitely for the Nudo ring--I absolutely love the combination of London blue topaz and amethyst. Gorgeous! My second choice would be for the other Pomellato ring, it is stunning. The Cartier pendant might be nice for everyday wear but it is quite small, when I saw it in person I was surprised at just how dainty it is.

I am always a sucker for deep color so I can't help voting for that, it is always so lovely to see on a lady's hand! Good luck with your decision and have a wonderful birthday!
Click to expand...


+1
I also have two nudos stacked, London blue topaz and the light blue topaz stone, I find it super comfortable and wear it daily.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top