Thank you for your sharing!When my daughter was your age my husband and I bought her a YG turquoise vintage alhambra pendant for Christmas one year. To this day it is one of her most cherished possessions. Since you have made up your mind between the two pieces I think you need to just see which one you like the most-it has to be a personal decision. Don't worry about the piece holding its value because if you plan on keeping it in your family it will not matter. I can only speak for for VCA on that topic - and VCA has held its value throughout the years. You might want to consider one of the Holiday Pendants that have a diamond in the center. I think they are usually available in October and you can also get it engraved on the back with your initals which would even make it more special to pass on someday. Below are two photos of my vintage pendants and the engraving by VCA.
Good Luck with whatever you decide to purchase.

LOVE all 3 of the alhambras, absolutely stunning! I never thought about the diamond design, I think that may be the perfect option, oh nooo I think my decision just became harder, you are such an enabler

