When you say worn out, do you mean they no longer stay on your feet /leather stretched? I’m interested in a pair and would love to hear your experience!
Gucci Loafers Advice Needed! - Brixton vs Jordaan
- Thread starter evajenny4
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
When you say worn out, do you mean they no longer stay on your feet /leather stretched? I’m interested in a pair and would love to hear your experience!
I ordered both the Brixton and the Jordaans (1/2 size down) to compare. The Jordanns fit me perfectly! The Brixton felt too wide....a little sloppy but do not know if another 1/2 size down would fit either - I returned those. They were comfortable but I did not care for the soft back......will not hold up long term imo.
I'm really surprised (and sad) to read that your Brixtons only lasted 6 months. This is incredibly inconsistent with my experience with Brixtons. I also never wear the heels down and have multiple pairs that I have purchased from different (authorized/legit) retailers and all have held up amazingly. Where did you purchase yours from? Gucci does do repairs, by the way, so I hope you do explore that before giving up on them!
My original pair are the off-white pair. I've had them about 6 months also and for several months (before I got multiple pairs) I wore them basically every single day and even wore them while walking around downtown to go shopping at outdoor malls and back and forth to dinner, well over half a mile to a mile of walking each way. And that pair is basically still in pristine condition, save for a teeny tiny scuff on the side that I haven't rubbed off yet (and the soles, obviously). You'd be hard-pressed to tell any discernible difference between that pair and my newer Brixtons that I've worn less than a handful of times.
Also, as an update to my earlier comment where I said that Jordaans run a half size larger than Brixtons, I have recently purchased a couple pairs of Jordaans and I wear the same size as in my Brixtons. I don't know if I misjudged when I had tried them on originally months ago and thought they were a bit larger (I'd say they're maybe 1/4 size larger than Brixton now, if anything, and fit perfect with a teeny insole in them) or if they're being made a bit smaller now, but I definitely wear a 37 in both Brixton and Jordaan. Maybe it's just the shape of my foot (I have a longer big toe than second toe), but 36.5 in either model my big toe grazes the tip of the shoe and I didn't want to risk that they wouldn't stretch at all in length or that my feet would swell any and be uncomfortable. But yes, I do agree you should try them on in-store to know for sure.
See my above feedback on how my Brixtons have lasted me. None of my Gucci loafers look anything but great, but of course how yours last will depend on a lot of factors. There are very few designer shoes I would ever wear in the rain, and Gucci loafers are not one of them. Frankly, I would highly advise against wearing ANY leather products in rain or snow, but absolutely would not wear a leather-soled shoe in those conditions. You wouldn't lay a designer purse down in the rain, would you? Why do it to your shoes then either?
From my experience, the leather is stretched and slightly faded. The soles damage pretty easily from just trying them on (like small stains, scuffs etc.). I wore them on average 3-4 times a week because they are comfortable. Unfortunately I was caught in the rain twice with them on within 6 months wear. I'm not sure where I heard that they offer soles for purchase but the Gucci store in Toronto didn't have this option.
Wow! I wish I had your experience but I did step in the rain (twice) with them on. That could be why they aren't as pristine as they should be. I purchased both pairs at Gucci's flagship store in Toronto. Like you, I've tried on 3 pairs of the same thing for the same size and noticed a slight difference in each pair. I repeated this cycle two more times (between sizes 36.5 to 37.5). The salesperson said since they are handmade, there are slight differences. This is why I encourage everyone to purchase in-store. I am not aware that they offer repairs. Do you know how much that would cost (rough estimate) to repair the soles? Are repairs only available in the US?
From my experience, the leather is stretched and slightly faded. The soles damage pretty easily from just trying them on (like small stains, scuffs etc.). I wore them on average 3-4 times a week because they are comfortable. Unfortunately I was caught in the rain twice with them on within 6 months wear. I'm not sure where I heard that they offer soles for purchase but the Gucci store in Toronto didn't have this option.
Wow. I'm very surprised to hear that your shoes faded. That seems very odd. The only wear any of mine show really is the crease horizontally in the middle of the front of the shoe where it kind of bubbles up a bit from being walked in (totally normal). I have a range of colors of Brixtons and Jordaans including off-white, light blue, and dark blue, and I have not experienced any fading with any shade of their leather.
I've never heard of Gucci offering soles for purchase, nor would I ever want to self-apply any soles. Every leather sole is going to wear, and much quicker than non-leather soles. It's important that after your soles begin to show some a lot of wear that you go to a cobbler that specializes in designer shoes (and make sure you ask to physically see their work) to have new soles (like Vibrams) put on your shoes. They will put rubber soles on the worn parts of your shoes and they will last pretty much forever. Vibram even makes red ones for Loubs. You can, of course, get these put on your soles right after purchase if you want, but it's not necessary. The cobbler will have to sand the bottom of your soles a bit to scuff them up enough for the adhesive to stick the Vibrams to the actual soles. Taking your shoes to a great cobbler will ensure that they will last you a lifetime.
In Canada, you can take your shoes (along with receipt) to any Gucci boutique and they will assist you in the repair process. I have not had this done, but I had seen it previously on their "Product Care" page on their website. Best of luck!
I recently ordered a pair of Gucci Brixton's and am patiently waiting for its arrival. Can anyone advise of a good leather protector / if getting the backs soled will help with the lifespan? I am curious about the wear and tear, as I intend to wear these as an everyday work shoe and take the subway in Toronto.
The difference between the Brixtons and the Jordaans is pretty pronounced when you see them in person. I am a huge fan of Gucci loafers and have sworn I'll be buried in them. Heaven on my feet! I just bought some black Brixtons this week. The deciding factor for me is that I plan to do a lot of walking around London this month on my trip. I can't risk stiff leather! It just won't work for me. The Jordaan was much stiffer when I checked it out in person. I don't plan to wear the Brixtons as a mule -- I just prefer the leather.
Also, just an observation: the pic of the Brixtons on this thread makes the leather look dull. In real life, they are nice and shiny.
Also, just an observation: the pic of the Brixtons on this thread makes the leather look dull. In real life, they are nice and shiny.
Does your off-white pair have creases? I have just received a pair of Princetown in off-white and they started creasing the minute I put them on... I am very afraid that it will get worse with time.. What is your experience? They are gorgeous but I want them to last forever!
Yes, they’re going to crease. Unless you don’t bend your foot when you walk, there’s no way for them not to crease.
i am fine with them "just" creasing, but will the leather deteriorates on that spot? your white ones, did they develop "fragile" leather on that part?
No, definitely not. They’re just creased from walking, everything else is the same. I’m to the point of needing to get mine resoled from how much I’ve worn them, and nothing else on them is even in remotely less than new shape except for the visual crease from walking.
jordan is better. you would love them. Go to store and see if they fit, for reference I am usually size 7.5 or 8 US size, but Jordan size 37Hi guys! New to the Gucci forum here! I'm looking to invest in my first pair of Gucci loafers, something very classic, so of course I am considering both the Jordaan and Brixton styles.
However I am a little confused about the differences between the two! Is the only difference that the Brixton can be folded down? Are there any other differences in terms of look, quality, fit etc? Is there a style that are considered more classic? The Brixton style is quite a bit cheaper and I was just wondering if this were for any particular reason.
Also, how do people generally find them in terms of comfort and sizing? Do they fit true to size? Should I size up/down or stick with my usual? I'm a 39 in the Gucci Marmont Pumps.
Any info you may have will be greatly appreciated!
I was having this same dilemma last year at this time, and I ended up going with the Brixtons, and I couldn’t be happier! The leather is like butter and there is a zero break- in period. I find the black to be so versatile, comfortable and classic. I don’t wear them as a mule, but I much prefer the softer leather. I found the Jordan to be a little stiff and far less comfortable. I purchased the 37 and I’m a 7M. I wear a 37 in the low heel Marmont, and a 37.5 in the Princetown.
the Summer versions used to have material lining to the uppers so with no show socks they’re very comfortable. when the loafers are leather lined (leather uppers towards the inside of the foot) it can get a bit sticky.