I'm not exactly neutral but I vote for keeping the Dinky

I don't have a saddlebag
yet (I have a full-size on the way), but the Dinky 24 is one of my favorite bags and the butterscotch in particular is gorgeous. I don't really like chain straps but I have plenty of other straps I can use with them. I think the Dinky shape is easier to dress up or down where the saddlebag is pretty casual.
Do you think they hold the same amounts? How much use have you got out of each?
My butterscotch with a Rogue strap

View attachment 3662340