Dinky Bag Clubhouse

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Trying to decide which to keep. My Dinky 24 in butterscotch or saddlebag 23 in butterscotch?

I'm not exactly neutral but I vote for keeping the Dinky :smile: I don't have a saddlebag yet (I have a full-size on the way), but the Dinky 24 is one of my favorite bags and the butterscotch in particular is gorgeous. I don't really like chain straps but I have plenty of other straps I can use with them. I think the Dinky shape is easier to dress up or down where the saddlebag is pretty casual.

Do you think they hold the same amounts? How much use have you got out of each?

My butterscotch with a Rogue strap :heart::heart:

IMG_1987.JPG
 
Trying to decide which to keep. My Dinky 24 in butterscotch or saddlebag 23 in butterscotch?

Do you find that it's annoying to lift the flap on your Saddlebag due to the buckle hardware that attaches the strap to the bag? Like you kind of need to navigate the strap around the buckles. (I returned my Saddle because of this.) For this reason, I think I sway to the Dinky 24 side of things.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wendyann7
I'm not exactly neutral but I vote for keeping the Dinky :smile: I don't have a saddlebag yet (I have a full-size on the way), but the Dinky 24 is one of my favorite bags and the butterscotch in particular is gorgeous. I don't really like chain straps but I have plenty of other straps I can use with them. I think the Dinky shape is easier to dress up or down where the saddlebag is pretty casual.

Do you think they hold the same amounts? How much use have you got out of each?

My butterscotch with a Rogue strap :heart::heart:

View attachment 3662340
Love this colour
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wendyann7
I'm not exactly neutral but I vote for keeping the Dinky :smile: I don't have a saddlebag yet (I have a full-size on the way), but the Dinky 24 is one of my favorite bags and the butterscotch in particular is gorgeous. I don't really like chain straps but I have plenty of other straps I can use with them. I think the Dinky shape is easier to dress up or down where the saddlebag is pretty casual.

Do you think they hold the same amounts? How much use have you got out of each?

My butterscotch with a Rogue strap :heart::heart:

View attachment 3662340
The combo is great. Love the color.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Inlovewithteaflower
I'm not exactly neutral but I vote for keeping the Dinky :smile: I don't have a saddlebag yet (I have a full-size on the way), but the Dinky 24 is one of my favorite bags and the butterscotch in particular is gorgeous. I don't really like chain straps but I have plenty of other straps I can use with them. I think the Dinky shape is easier to dress up or down where the saddlebag is pretty casual.

Do you think they hold the same amounts? How much use have you got out of each?

My butterscotch with a Rogue strap :heart::heart:

View attachment 3662340
Hi, do you mind sharing a picture of the inside of your butterscotch Dinky 24 and the full number inside on the white tag? I just got one off ebay, but something doesn't seem quite right even though comparing it to pictures looks good, the leather isn't as buttery as my saddle. thank you!
 
Hi, do you mind sharing a picture of the inside of your butterscotch Dinky 24 and the full number inside on the white tag? I just got one off ebay, but something doesn't seem quite right even though comparing it to pictures looks good, the leather isn't as buttery as my saddle. thank you!

Sure, I won't be home until tomorrow night though. I will say - I have the butterscotch, azure and chalk dinky 24s and I wouldn't call any of them buttery. They feel kind of dry-ish. I don't know how better to explain it, sorry!
 
Sure, I won't be home until tomorrow night though. I will say - I have the butterscotch, azure and chalk dinky 24s and I wouldn't call any of them buttery. They feel kind of dry-ish. I don't know how better to explain it, sorry!
ah, thank you! yes, dry-ish is what this feels like. I only have 2 other dinkys, but not the 1941, the ones from Macys. Thank you for the help!
 
Top