Ok bag lovers, I’m back.... back with both Rogue bags!!! And still undecided. Thank you to all of you who posted their vote and/or opinions. But they are asked for again! So I ended up buying both rogues to see them in person. I viewed them both at the store but find their lighting difficult. So.... brought them home. Here are pics of them at home. Are you all still leaning to the green? Appreciate your thoughts. Geez... wish I could keep both. The chalk bag is softer leather for some reason and maybe it’s just me, but feels lighter!.#?
Decisions, decisions...which Coach bag?
- Thread starter Marlies
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
I still love the green more. Great color to wear all year long.
I think you love the chalk! Keep what you love. Don’t worry about anyone else. They are both beautiful.
This is one of my “pros” for the green. Can be used anytime of year!
Lol... I think I really do. I keep trying to convince myself. I think my problem is I love them both so much but in reality I’d likely use the green more. And something about those whip stitch handles on the green have me. But the chalk is so soft. Lol
Ah, really! Awesome. It’s such a lovely bag and so perfect for summer. It’s ever so slightly lighter in weight than the green too. Others have mentioned colour transfer, are you concerned of that happening? Or did you treat it?
Keep the dark one. I used my Chalk Rogue tote and had quite a few spots. I had to remove them with moisturizer.
Just got it & haven't carried it yet. However, I also have a pebbled leather saddle bag that is a couple years old. I sprayed it with Apple leather guard & the only area where transfer happened & did NOT come off was on the fabric by the zipper.
That said, it is not a bag that I'm going to reach for frequently. It would never be my weekend bag to run around town with. I do feel like I would be more careful with it.
Both are beautiful! As much as I love my neutrals and want to say chalk, white leather just seems so high maintenance/worrisome. The closest I’ve gotten is my Beechwood Rogue 25 that has white panels on either end. The green is beautiful and I love the whip stitch detail so you really can’t go wrong!
I love the green and then the chalk! I'd be concerned about keeping the fabric one clean over time. It sounds like you love the chalk and the denim the most. Are you able to exchange for a Rogue 25 since you prefer a smaller size?View attachment 4445031 View attachment 4445030 View attachment 4445029 hello fellow bag lovers! I’m finding myself in quite the little predicament... I can’t make up my mind on which bag to keep. I love all 3 but can only have one.. I was hoping to hear your thoughts and help me decide. Below is the breakdown I have done to help me decide. Please add any thoughts, opinions you might have. If you have any of these bags, I’d love to see IRL pics - They are welcomed!
My fave/everyday bag at the moment is a red pebbled Edie shoulder bag. Medium size - it actually holds a lot !
Coach Rogue 30 Chalk colour
What I Love : Love the colour ( it’s on off white, not bright white). Love the daisies on the tag and the pins. LOVE how soft this leather is. It’s softer than the green one.
Concerns: worried it will lose too much shape. SA told me that because the leather is so soft and due to the weight of the rivets it will likely lose its shape more than the non riveted ones. Maybe too big for me.
Has a fair bit of weight to it - due to beautiful leather!
Coach Rogue 30 Teal (green) the pic appears brighter than it actually is.
What I love: love the whip stitched handles. Wow!! Love that the colour appears different in different light. Love the contrast and the sueded centre.
Concerns: colour might be too bland for me at times.
Has a fair bit of weight to it - due to beautiful leather!
Coach Carly Denim
What I love: it’s retro! Love the denim! I assume it would be lighter than the two above.
Concerns: only one big open space inside. Has interior zip up and two cell pouches but no dividers. Just open concept. Wonder if when under arm will “bow” in the middle.
They are both gorgeous! I love the green one more because I love the blue/green color range. The chalk is just as gorgeous but will take more care because of the light color. I love the look of white bags too.
I voted green. It’s so pretty! My eyes are drawn to the color and the whipstitch details. I also like that neutral interior peeking out. While I don’t prefer the style of the Rogue bags (too boxy and structured), I cannot deny this is one beautiful bag!