Deciding between Magnolia & Rose Extreme

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

L

LilC0322

Member
Apr 26, 2015
31
32
#1
Hi!:smile: I’m having a hard time deciding between a bag in Magnolia and Rose Extreme. Both are in Clemence leather.

I’m looking for a fun, happy color! From the photos that I have seen, Magnolia appears to be more of a Barbie pink, while RE seems more strawberry. Would one of the colors be more likely to have color transfer? Of course, I would try my best to keep them clean.

I would be extremely appreciative of any insight or opinions. Thanks!:flowers:
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChanelCelineLaurentLover and Orangefanatic
#2
They are very different colors in my opinion. My Constance is Rose Extreme (Epsom) while my Evelyne TPM is Magnolia (Clemence). You can see the RE is an almost neon reddish pink while magnolia is more of a purple leaning pink - though not as purpley as Rose Pourpre (the Bastia pictured). Which bag are you searching for for these colors? I can’t imagine RE in anything large.
09D02BA4-3B61-4424-A507-98AD1FB11881.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: celebrationfl, germanshepard, Skybunny and 17 others
#6
Thank you ladies! Your input is very much appreciated.

I’m looking at the mini Evelyne. That’s why I’m looking for a fun color. I totally agree the the PE would be too much on a large bag. @acrowcounted, you’re photo is so helpful, and I love your collection! I think I might be leaning towards the magnolia at this point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Orangefanatic
#8
LilC0322 said:
Thank you ladies! Your input is very much appreciated.

I’m looking at the mini Evelyne. That’s why I’m looking for a fun color. I totally agree the the PE would be too much on a large bag. @acrowcounted, you’re photo is so helpful, and I love your collection! I think I might be leaning towards the magnolia at this point.
Click to expand...
One or the other won't disappoint you. Both are beautiful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BBC, LilC0322 and Bentley143
#11
Rose Extreme is not hot pink. RE is watermelon red. Rose Shocking & Rose Tyrien are Hot Pink....
Seeing is believing... Here are Rose Shocking, RE and Rose Jaipur together with no filter in natural lighting... I can tell you that THIS is how RE looks IRL... it's stunning but not (what I call) hot pink. Mag has more white in it so it's not quite a hot pink but it is also very beautiful pink. HTH!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_E0548.JPG
    IMG_E0548.JPG
    199 KB · Views: 1,527
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: amaretti_, celebrationfl, rickysakura and 18 others
#12
Israeli_Flava said:
Rose Extreme is not hot pink. RE is watermelon red. Rose Shocking & Rose Tyrien are Hot Pink....
Seeing is believing... Here are Rose Shocking, RE and Rose Jaipur together with no filter in natural lighting... I can tell you that THIS is how RE looks IRL... it's stunning but not (what I call) hot pink. Mag has more white in it so it's not quite a hot pink but it is also very beautiful pink. HTH!
Click to expand...
Agreed. My rose extreme is exactly as you say.. very watermelon-y. I was Very very unsure about this color as it is not quite red and not quite pink. Now that I’ve worn it a few times i am liking it more and more. It is a great pop, but better in smaller bags in my opinion. Here is my C18 in Swift rose extreme.
 

Attachments

  • A88A385C-A49D-41EB-BF13-2B3ABBCD5688.jpeg
    A88A385C-A49D-41EB-BF13-2B3ABBCD5688.jpeg
    161.8 KB · Views: 1,346
  • Like
Reactions: Virevolte, step2005, amaretti_ and 18 others
#13
@acrowcounted do you find that either magnolia or RE is easier to pair with clothes? I wear a lot of grey, navy, and aqua. I don’t want a bag that I can only wear with one outfit, because the undertone makes it hard to wear. I’m kind of tempted to order a Hapi 3 bracelet in each color to see the colors in real life. I’m just more sure that I can wait that long. Lol Clearly, I’m making this way more difficult than it should be. Yikes!

@Israeli_Flava & @GoldFish8 thank you for sharing your lovely pictures! I think that if I were getting a Constance, I would jump on that in a heartbeat!
 
  • Like
Reactions: chinamom
#14
LilC0322 said:
@acrowcounted do you find that either magnolia or RE is easier to pair with clothes? I wear a lot of grey, navy, and aqua. I don’t want a bag that I can only wear with one outfit, because the undertone makes it hard to wear. I’m kind of tempted to order a Hapi 3 bracelet in each color to see the colors in real life. I’m just more sure that I can wait that long. Lol Clearly, I’m making this way more difficult than it should be. Yikes!

@Israeli_Flava & @GoldFish8 thank you for sharing your lovely pictures! I think that if I were getting a Constance, I would jump on that in a heartbeat!
Click to expand...
I think they both work well with grey and navy, and probably neither with Audi but it would depend on the exact shade. RE is pretty bright but I think I prefer it, however, you can't go wrong with either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LilC0322
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top