Given that they were 50% off, I think it's okay for you to keep both!![]()
I should know better than to ask for return advice on this forum.

I actually think that I'm going to return the City Willis in the British Tan. I just realized that I own an original Willis, with the dowel, in British Tan. That's probably why I liked the new City Willis in British Tan so much. Now you know I'm a true addict if I didn't even remember that I owned a bag that was so similar already.