Okay, I'm starting to think the whole light toenail polish look in peep toes looks weird. Marisa Miller looks okay, I suppose, but her toenails bug me. And when I see French Pedicures in peep toes it often make it look like there are claws sticking out.
I think it looks weird with a light colored shoe. I often wear a darker shoe with a light polish or a light shoe with a dark polish. Your shoe color and polish color shouldn't match though...I think that's what looks weird.