I have found if I have to think about a bag vs going with my gut when I see a bag, the bag is not for me. I've been lusting for the teal since I first saw a pic, and I am a blue and purple bag girl. So I'm going for the teal! My BFF asked me why I am so smitten with the Bals and I told her they represent how I feel about my life. Worn and sometimes distressed, but coming out on the other side better with wear!GET WHAT YOU WANT .. do not let him talk you into something that you won't like/use!!!
I have not seen the Blue/Teal IRL, however, I've seen plenty of pictures of it and it does look very pretty. I can't stress enough though, that you really don't want to buy something that you will end up not using, especially since the Hamilton bags are not inexpensive (okay - yes, a lot less expensive than Chanel or Hermes, but you KWIM)!
PS: I loved the pic of the '05 Rouge and bid on one on Ebay. I love the red and glad to hear the color has stayed true over time.