I have to say my Whiskey Ali bag does scratch a lot, but rubbing it also does make it look okay again. Today was the real test, because it poured down rain the whole time. I had bet (perhaps unwisely) that the water spots would dry out and not show permanently, and hallelujah I was right. It's so nice to finally have a good leather bag that I don't have to be afraid to take out in bad weather. Yay, Coach!