I think the bucket is very cute but more suitable for very casual/sporty days than every day wear! The other one is ok too, but I currently have a small crush om bucket bags ...
I love the vintage feel of the bucket with the vintage revival of Gucci coated canvas. However I would imagine that the bucket is less practical since it doesn’t have a zipper and things could fall out quite easily? I don’t own a bucket style bag because of that but maybe it’s sturdier than it seems?
I’m going to have to say the top handle. It has a wide zipper and if you have to put extra stuff in it, it won’t get crushed as it would with the draw string bag. Hope that makes sense.