Bronze Valentino vs. Gold Mansur Gavriel - which one to keep?

[Elena S]

Have hard time deciding between these two. Got both with 40% off, but can't justify keeping both. I like it how lightweight Mansur Gavriel is (Valentino is significantly heavier), but I already have it in black, so am afraid to regret it. Don't have any Valentino bags yet. Spikes look quite cool!

 

[IntheOcean]

Valentino hands down. Beautiful design & color and the strap length is perfect for your height. I'm not a fan of the MG bag, perhaps it would've looked better if it was a clutch, but with the strap, it looks kind of awkward.

 

[Tomsmom]

I really like the Valentino.

 

[Elena S]

Valentino hands down. Beautiful design & color and the strap length is perfect for your height. I'm not a fan of the MG bag, perhaps it would've looked better if it was a clutch, but with the strap, it looks kind of awkward.

Mansur Gavriel is actually a clutch - the strap is removable I feel like Valentino strap is a bit too long for me to be honest. I prefer my crossbodies to hit above my hip. So still not sure...

 

[baghagg]

These bags are so completely different that keeping both would not be "wrong" (lol), but if I was going to choose one it would be the Valentino! It's gorgeous and it falls to a perfect spot on you!

 

[IntheOcean]

Mansur Gavriel is actually a clutch - the strap is removable I feel like Valentino strap is a bit too long for me to be honest. I prefer my crossbodies to hit above my hip. So still not sure...

As far as I can see, the strap is adjustable on the Valentino bag.

 

[Elena S]

As far as I can see, the strap is adjustable on the Valentino bag.

It’s already on the shortest setting

 

[Elena S]

I actually figured out a way to wear it as a shoulder bag

 

[IntheOcean]

I actually figured out a way to wear it as a shoulder bag

That looks great!