Well, I ended up going with the Butterscotch. I knew I wouldn't find it through actual Coach, so I went on the hunt through Poshmark, Ebay, Amazon, etc. I found one on Poshmark that was described as "Like New" condition, and looked great in the pictures so I went ahead and ordered it.
Unfortunately, it was delivered today, and was not "Like New" in my opinion. The outside was fine but the navy blue suede lining, which is hard to inspect only through pictures apparently, had a few stains that I was not told about by the seller. For what I paid for it, I can't let the stains slide, so I'll be sending it back.
It's a huge bummer because it really is a gorgeous color, I almost seriously considered keeping the bag because I know it will be nearly impossible to find another Butterscotch.
So back to square one I go lol.