Black, Butterscotch, or Prussian Blue?

Which color should I choose?

  • Total voters
    53

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

L

lmelcx3

Member
May 23, 2019
6
46
#1
After overthinking it entirely too much, I've decided to finally buy a Rogue. I've narrowed it down to these 3 after spending entirely too much time looking at all the colors possible, but now I'm completely stuck between these 3 because they're all so gorgeous!

The black is such a classic and I love the interior contrast color
black.PNG
The Butterscotch is so unique and the perfect fall color butterscotch.PNG
And the Prussian Blue is chic but with an edge
blue prussian.PNG

Help a girl out, y'all. :hrmm:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Smallcoach
#2
lmelcx3 said:
After overthinking it entirely too much, I've decided to finally buy a Rogue. I've narrowed it down to these 3 after spending entirely too much time looking at all the colors possible, but now I'm completely stuck between these 3 because they're all so gorgeous!

The black is such a classic and I love the interior contrast color
View attachment 4520149
The Butterscotch is so unique and the perfect fall color View attachment 4520150
And the Prussian Blue is chic but with an edge
View attachment 4520151

Help a girl out, y'all. :hrmm:
Click to expand...

I like the butterscotch Rogue! It's a really unique shade and if you're wearing other fall colors as part of your wardrobe (such as shades of brown, reds, oranges- preferably darker, eggplant purple, or even neutrals) it would be a beautiful addition. It all depends on your taste.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lmelcx3 and Smallcoach
#3
I‘ve never seen the Prussian blue in person, but I‘ve always wondered if those handles with the stitches are comfortable, especially when the bag is quite heavy....
I own the black rogue and I just find it very plain, I intend to customize it next time I am in a store that does customizations.... I use my dark denim rogue much more.
So I would vote for the butterscotch, it looks like a beautiful color. Is this still available for sale at Coach?
 
  • Like
Reactions: lmelcx3
#4
Definitely black! The black/black Rogue looks so rock and roll, and cool with the matching hardware. I don't know how well the hardware holds up with use, but I wouldn't be able to resist a Rogue in that combo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lmelcx3
#6
Prussian Blue! I love blues. :biggrin: I agree that the butterscotch is a unique and beautiful shade for fall! It wouldn't go well with my wardrobe. Have fun choosing the one you love the most!
 
  • Like
Reactions: lmelcx3
#8
That blue is gorgeous IRL. All over that one.

I don’t like the mustard interior of the black and the butterscotch will be prone to marks so that is a no for my lifestyle. But they are all really nice choices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lmelcx3
#10
If you are only getting one, I would base it on how much it goes with your wardrobe. I tend to wear a lot of neutral colors in clothing, so my bags tend to be colors that are not necessarily neutral. So if you wear a lot of navy, black, beige, gray, white, etc. I'd go with Butterscotch. If you wear more vibrant colors and or prints, I'd consider the black or Prussian blue to coordinate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lmelcx3
#13
Well, I ended up going with the Butterscotch. I knew I wouldn't find it through actual Coach, so I went on the hunt through Poshmark, Ebay, Amazon, etc. I found one on Poshmark that was described as "Like New" condition, and looked great in the pictures so I went ahead and ordered it.

Unfortunately, it was delivered today, and was not "Like New" in my opinion. The outside was fine but the navy blue suede lining, which is hard to inspect only through pictures apparently, had a few stains that I was not told about by the seller. For what I paid for it, I can't let the stains slide, so I'll be sending it back. :sad:

It's a huge bummer because it really is a gorgeous color, I almost seriously considered keeping the bag because I know it will be nearly impossible to find another Butterscotch.

So back to square one I go lol.
 
#14
Chicagogirl2005 said:
I‘ve never seen the Prussian blue in person, but I‘ve always wondered if those handles with the stitches are comfortable, especially when the bag is quite heavy....
I own the black rogue and I just find it very plain, I intend to customize it next time I am in a store that does customizations.... I use my dark denim rogue much more.
So I would vote for the butterscotch, it looks like a beautiful color. Is this still available for sale at Coach?
Click to expand...
Nope, unfortunately not. Had to check out the prelove market to even find either the Butterscotch or the Prussian Blue! :-s
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top