Birkin 30 vs Kelly 28

[am2022]

I say kelly !!! ❤️

 

[Israeli_Flava]

I voted for Kelly sellier 28. That is the ideal size for sellier and in the ideal color/hw combo IMO.
I am a Birkin girl, but I own one B30 in epsom (since 2014) and I don't care for this leather as it ages.
I will never buy another B in epsom. That's just my experience. I don't hate epsom leather. Actually I have also owned quite a few kelly's and constance in epsom and it has been fantastic for those styles. Ideally I would pick chevre for everything but alas, that is not possible. Anyway, although the birkin is light as a feather in epsom (which is the main benefit), it is not visually pleasing to me over time and I don't care for the texture of it. For me, in birkin, togo is the best after chevre. Just my random thoughts.

 

[Kitty S.]

I currently have an alligator K28 Retourne, constance, Evelyn.. I do use my kelly more than the Birkin

I vote for Kelly just because you prefer shoulder bags. B30 is my favorite H bag, but you should keep the bag that you will use more.

 

[880]

This! While my heart prefers a Birkin, with these specs, I voted that you keep the Kelly.

If both had been in Togo, I would have voted to keep the Birkin.

+1

 

[peggioka]

I voted for Kelly 28 sellier, because I like the shoulder strip option.