Roo, I had a noisette box birkin and my recollection is that it was very similar to my current natural barenia in terms of color. Box has the shine which gives it a dressier feel. Personally I prefer palladium (brushed even better) with both natural barenia and noisette box.
Hi rockerchic - I had a flick through the brown colour thread, and think I found you noisette birkin - what a pretty bag that was!
I probably wouldn't go for box again as I have a bbb - and wanted something more carefree. (My togo or epsom are fab because, although I do carry a longchamps inside - I generally don't worry about showers, - downpours, now that's another matter!)
I'm guessing the feel and texture is what makes barenia so special - looked at belt again and wondering if tadelakt might feel a little flat in comparison? Barenia lovers, please feel free to elucidate!
Glad another in favour of the phw - see a few examples in the colour thread and it still looks wonderful!