Without knowing where the sellers got them, I wouldn't be comfortable verifying any of them. I'm still looking into it but none of those was ever sold separately and the only one that actually looks like the charm that was included with the Hamptons Leather Satchel is the third one. The second seller is making jewelry from Coach charms wihout disclosing that the items are handmade, which is against Ebay's rules. Legally those handmade pieces can't be listed as Coach since Coach isn't the final manufacturer.