I think the whole Salma Hayek picture was taken unflatteringly. She is carrying the version with knotted detail all scrunched up, in front of her. The beauty in this bag is its long silhouette and sensual folds. She is carrying it like a sack.
Personally, I really liked the knotted detail at first. In the photo, the knot adds too much complexity to the outfit. Now, I think it adds to much complexity to an outfit. The outfit needs to be very plain to balance the complexity of the folds and knot. In the metal detail version, the plain metal handle balances the folds very well and also, it does not allow itself to be held like a sack.
Personally, I really liked the knotted detail at first. In the photo, the knot adds too much complexity to the outfit. Now, I think it adds to much complexity to an outfit. The outfit needs to be very plain to balance the complexity of the folds and knot. In the metal detail version, the plain metal handle balances the folds very well and also, it does not allow itself to be held like a sack.