All the same price - help!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

#17
I remember I used to love Coach about 15 years ago, when they started to get really popular. Strayed away and started collecting LV, Chanel etc. Last week I walked by a Coach store and fell in love with the Cassie. I have been trying to get the LV Pochette Metis in the monogram for the longest time, but could never get my hands on it. I am really digging the Cassie because the style is so similar yet very understated which is what I like. I don't like any of the colors that are out at the moment, and have enough black bags, so will wait until a nice cognac/brown color comes out. Fingers crossed that more colors will become available once we change seasons. Anyways, sorry for the long post, but I vote for for the Cassie!
 
  • Like
Reactions: faintlymacabre, TangerineKandy and crunchybiscuit98
#18
I'm a fan of the Cassie, love the look, it seems very classic and versatile. I also love that type of lock on Coach bags, I have Coach bags with that lock and I've always found them very easy to use. I'm not so keen on the Rogue, it reminds me too much of the Lady Dior bag, and the more pointy corners will maybe show wear a little quicker.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ccbaggirl89 and crunchybiscuit98
#19
PuccaNGaru said:
I remember I used to love Coach about 15 years ago, when they started to get really popular. Strayed away and started collecting LV, Chanel etc. Last week I walked by a Coach store and fell in love with the Cassie. I have been trying to get the LV Pochette Metis in the monogram for the longest time, but could never get my hands on it. I am really digging the Cassie because the style is so similar yet very understated which is what I like. I don't like any of the colors that are out at the moment, and have enough black bags, so will wait until a nice cognac/brown color comes out. Fingers crossed that more colors will become available once we change seasons. Anyways, sorry for the long post, but I vote for for the Cassie!
Click to expand...
no worries, i love the long posts! really hoping that more colors come out too because omg that would be amazing!!! thanks for the input!!
 
#20
Anesthestia said:
I'm a fan of the Cassie, love the look, it seems very classic and versatile. I also love that type of lock on Coach bags, I have Coach bags with that lock and I've always found them very easy to use. I'm not so keen on the Rogue, it reminds me too much of the Lady Dior bag, and the more pointy corners will maybe show wear a little quicker.
Click to expand...
my thoughts exactly on the rogue bag: that’s why i didn’t like it at first. i think the MTO made me change my mind though! and i agree 100% on you with the cassie!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anesthestia
#22
okay, so i know that these aren’t the best pictures, but i did my best with the sensors attached at macy’s lol

i didn’t consider the signature at first because i didn’t like it but omg, she’s a beauty! it’s really growing on me :) what do you all think? hubby’s trying some stuff on right now, so i’ll post a try-on shot of the rogue when i get to the boutique if they have it. looking forward to everyone’s thoughts!
DA37F696-55C6-4265-A09D-60529DE9DAA7.jpeg BB5427F5-6C1E-404E-9A97-F74B1A834502.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: focoach, Thistle and Crystice
#23
daniellainez67 said:
okay, so i know that these aren’t the best pictures, but i did my best with the sensors attached at macy’s lol

i didn’t consider the signature at first because i didn’t like it but omg, she’s a beauty! it’s really growing on me :smile: what do you all think? hubby’s trying some stuff on right now, so i’ll post a try-on shot of the rogue when i get to the boutique if they have it. looking forward to everyone’s thoughts!
View attachment 4462044 View attachment 4462048
Click to expand...
I’m still partial to the blue one (then again I love blue!).
 
  • Like
Reactions: TangerineKandy and crunchybiscuit98
#26
Pagan said:
For quality and utility reasons, I would go for a non-cystom Rogue. The price point now is compelling and the design is discontinued.
Click to expand...
I agree with Pagen- but it depends on how much space you need. The rogues are at a great price point now and would offer more room. The Cassie is great for a lightweight more organized option. They are both great! I have three regular size rogues and just got my Cassie last week. :panic: I was torn between the black and the rust and signature canvas. I got the rust one:graucho:
 
  • Like
Reactions: crunchybiscuit98
#27
These bags are really different. However it seems you do prefer the blue. The rogue made to order is a lovely concept and unique. But as far as style and function I’d go with the Cassie. I just picked one up in the pink.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crunchybiscuit98
#28
Crystice said:
I agree with Pagen- but it depends on how much space you need. The rogues are at a great price point now and would offer more room. The Cassie is great for a lightweight more organized option. They are both great! I have three regular size rogues and just got my Cassie last week. :panic: I was torn between the black and the rust and signature canvas. I got the rust one:graucho:
Click to expand...
i think you made the right choice, i really might just go with the rust & signature canvas!! will update the thread on what i choose :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Crystice
#29
kvm87 said:
These bags are really different. However it seems you do prefer the blue. The rogue made to order is a lovely concept and unique. But as far as style and function I’d go with the Cassie. I just picked one up in the pink.
Click to expand...
i hope you love it!!! i love the blue, and maybe i’ll get it later, but i wasn’t in love with the snakeskin handle :/
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top