All the same price - help!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

crunchybiscuit98

crunchybiscuit98

dandan98
Jun 4, 2017
174
976
#1
Hello everyone! It's been a while since I've had an everyday bag (maybe ever), and I'm ready to buy a new Coach bag because I love their designs - so cute!!! I know that the bags I'm going to list here are all completely different, but I don't carry that much so it won't make a huge difference on what I finally decide. (Aside from the price.)

The first is the Cassie crossbody in blue pebbled leather, refined calf leather, suede, and snakeskin handle. ($395) The second is the Central tote (also $395), and the last is a Made To Order Rogue in the 25 size. ($795) I would have to save some more money for the rogue.

All of them are gorgeous! I have yet to try any of these on, so I plan to go to the boutique at the end of the week to get some feelers. My wardrobe is very casual. Thanks in advance! (Also feel free to drop the Coach bags y'all are rocking! It would help even more if someone had this exact Cassie or the central tote:nuts:)
73768_v5d61_a0.jpg 69453_v5oqr_a0.jpg download.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: bellebellebelle19
#3
ShoeSquirrel said:
I vote for the Cassie simply because I love the look of it but the functionality doesn’t work for how and what I carry in my bags. I want to selfishly live vicariously through you. :smile:

That being said, I personally think the Rogue is one of greatest bags I’ve ever found from any designer.
Click to expand...
hahaha that's fair! and thank you! i think i'm leaning more towards the cassie :) while the rogue is rumored to be *gasp* discontinued, i think it'll be smart to save that for later, seeing that the MTO option will probably still be around for a while!
 
  • Like
Reactions: ShoeSquirrel
#5
All three are different styles, so I would base the decision on which one you need more of in your closet. Meaning, is this going to be a regular everyday, all the time, handbag? What other bags do you own, so if you are looking for a variety, it's not something similar? I personally am a fan of the Rogues, it's my favorite style. I own 3 of the regular size, 1 of the 25, and a satchel. The 25 is a terrific option because it is versatile in how you can wear it. (shoulder bag, long shoulder, crossbody, satchel, hand carry)

I own a Court bag, which I believe is what the Cassie design is inspired by. I like it as crossbody bag, but it is not an every day bag for me, I have other crossbodies I tend to reach for if I am wearing it for longer than say, a weekend or travelling. The tote, you cannot go wrong, but IMO a tote is a tote is a tote. I own 2 Market totes and while I like them a lot, and use them from time to time, they aren't handbags that set my heart a flutter if that makes sense :biggrin:

So at the end of the day, I'd go with a Rogue 25. Are there any ready to wear colors that you'd consider? Because I believe almost all Rogues are on sale now since they will be discontinued. Then it would be in the same price point as the the other two on your list. Hope that helped, and didn't make it more difficult to choose!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tosa22 and crunchybiscuit98
#7
CoachMaven said:
All three are different styles, so I would base the decision on which one you need more of in your closet. Meaning, is this going to be a regular everyday, all the time, handbag? What other bags do you own, so if you are looking for a variety, it's not something similar? I personally am a fan of the Rogues, it's my favorite style. I own 3 of the regular size, 1 of the 25, and a satchel. The 25 is a terrific option because it is versatile in how you can wear it. (shoulder bag, long shoulder, crossbody, satchel, hand carry)

I own a Court bag, which I believe is what the Cassie design is inspired by. I like it as crossbody bag, but it is not an every day bag for me, I have other crossbodies I tend to reach for if I am wearing it for longer than say, a weekend or travelling. The tote, you cannot go wrong, but IMO a tote is a tote is a tote. I own 2 Market totes and while I like them a lot, and use them from time to time, they aren't handbags that set my heart a flutter if that makes sense :biggrin:

So at the end of the day, I'd go with a Rogue 25. Are there any ready to wear colors that you'd consider? Because I believe almost all Rogues are on sale now since they will be discontinued. Then it would be in the same price point as the the other two on your list. Hope that helped, and didn't make it more difficult to choose!
Click to expand...
that's funny, i just discovered that the Cassie is possibly a "modern" take on the Court. and i totally understand what you mean by the heart flutters :lol: i think i feel that with the custom rogue 25, mainly because i got to customize it.

as for the ready to wear, i have considered the olive with rivets - which you're right, it would be about the same as the other bags!! oh man, just when i thought it couldn't be any harder :eek: however, i do think you ruled out the tote for me (hopefully down the road it'll go on sale). thank you so much!!
 
#9
daniellainez67 said:
Hello everyone! It's been a while since I've had an everyday bag (maybe ever), and I'm ready to buy a new Coach bag because I love their designs - so cute!!! I know that the bags I'm going to list here are all completely different, but I don't carry that much so it won't make a huge difference on what I finally decide. (Aside from the price.)

The first is the Cassie crossbody in blue pebbled leather, refined calf leather, suede, and snakeskin handle. ($395) The second is the Central tote (also $395), and the last is a Made To Order Rogue in the 25 size. ($795) I would have to save some more money for the rogue.

All of them are gorgeous! I have yet to try any of these on, so I plan to go to the boutique at the end of the week to get some feelers. My wardrobe is very casual. Thanks in advance! (Also feel free to drop the Coach bags y'all are rocking! It would help even more if someone had this exact Cassie or the central tote:nuts:)
View attachment 4458738 View attachment 4458739 View attachment 4458740
Click to expand...
The Cassie! Looks like a good bag to wear and is cute!
 
  • Like
Reactions: crunchybiscuit98
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top