36 mm Rolex Too Big?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Kind of curious, for those who got a 36 mm DJ did any of you regret not getting a 31 mm?
I bought a 31 since I have small wrists. While I love it and felt the 28 was too small for me, part of me wishes I had also tried the 36 for an additional size comparison. No regrets on my 31, mind you, but bigger watches are in, so…

Here’s the 31 on me, in case you’re curious. If I recall correctly, my wrist measures just over 5” around.

IMG_2612.jpeg
 
I bought a 31 since I have small wrists. While I love it and felt the 28 was too small for me, part of me wishes I had also tried the 36 for an additional size comparison. No regrets on my 31, mind you, but bigger watches are in, so…

Here’s the 31 on me, in case you’re curious. If I recall correctly, my wrist measures just over 5” around.

View attachment 6057609

I think that size looks perfect on you! :smile: Beautiful color dial, too.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: DME
lol funny how it’s changed.
10 years ago 36 would be considered small and Daytona was the most popular size!

I have Ladyjust, 31 and 36. All of them are great for me. 36 for more casual jeans day. I’m 5.10 so all look good on me.
 
  • Insightful
  • Like
Reactions: blinggirl74 and DME
I think that size looks perfect on you! :smile: Beautiful color dial, too.
Thank you so much! It’s the mint green dial. I had not expected to get a Rolex and definitely would not have thought about a green dial in any watch brand would be to my liking, but I tried on several options in the boutique (both 28 and 31) and this one was love at first sight.
 
  • Like
Reactions: etoile de mer
I think it depends on wrist size…
I have little wrists (5”) and bought my 31mm, then referred to as “midsize” about 15 or so years ago. It’s remained perfect size for me, and my personal preference.
A 36 presidential is on my list.

DH surprised me with a 39mm Hublot but because of its shape, it doesn’t really seem bigger than my Rolex to me.
 
I bought a 31 since I have small wrists. While I love it and felt the 28 was too small for me, part of me wishes I had also tried the 36 for an additional size comparison. No regrets on my 31, mind you, but bigger watches are in, so…

Here’s the 31 on me, in case you’re curious. If I recall correctly, my wrist measures just over 5” around.

View attachment 6057609
I actually have a 31 and was undecided between that and the 36.I still think about the 36 but remember thinking maybe it was too big. First two are mine and last two I tried on in store that was 36
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1283.jpeg
    IMG_1283.jpeg
    73.1 KB · Views: 143
  • IMG_1490.jpeg
    IMG_1490.jpeg
    37.5 KB · Views: 145
  • IMG_1489.jpeg
    IMG_1489.jpeg
    53.8 KB · Views: 151
  • IMG_1464.jpeg
    IMG_1464.jpeg
    96.4 KB · Views: 147
I actually have a 31 and was undecided between that and the 36.I still think about the 36 but remember thinking maybe it was too big. First two are mine and last two I tried on in store that was 36
Both the 31 and 36 look great on you! And there’s always the next one, so… :smile:
 
2008 - Rolex Lady Datejust 26mm, TT MOP, diamond markers.

2017 - Rolex Datejust 31mm, SS Pink dial, Roman numeral

2024 - Placed interest for Rolex Oyster Perpetual 36mm, SS Celebration dial

I think I might get it in 4 years’ time. I’m 5th in the list and the store only received one 36mm in the last 12 months! 🫣

To OP, yes, I went bigger and bigger 😆. In 2017, when we could walk in and get any watch, SA told me to consider 34mm, that was in my wishlist too but too bad that size has been discontinued.
 
I have super small wrists and just bought the Lady Datejust 28 today!! I adore her and can’t stop staring at her!!! Here are a 36, two 31’s and my 28 on my wrist. Good luck with your decision. Any Rolex is a great choice! ❤️👑

View attachment 6061706View attachment 6061707View attachment 6061708View attachment 6061709


View attachment 6061710
Thanks! I have a 31 and was thinking about a potential trade but I like that the 31 isn’t so in your face
 
  • Love
Reactions: Mrs.Mac28
Top