35 Birkin Too Big?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

#2
HbH I don't really think it's a matter of your size, but more your "look" I am taller than you and prefer 30s for all but travel. More of a handbag than a tote.

Do you generally prefer bigger bags? Which bags do you most like to carry now?
 
#3
Hi, there are lots of pictures you can compare different sizes in the reference library thread! I am 5.4 and I just got a 35 but I am dying for a 40 now,lol....it all depends on how much you need to carry in the bag and of course how the size looks on you. Why don´t you try and get to an H-store and try out the different sizes?

eta: like handybags said, it all depends on your "look"!

I am a BIG bag gal;)

Kat
 
#5
I'm the same height as you, small-framed, and most of my Birkins are 35cm!

In fact, I posted a pic of me carrying the exact bag - 35cm Gold Togo GHW, in the "Hermes in Action" thread recently!
There are many members carrying Birkins of various sizes in that thread, you may like to take a look and compare to see what suits your style:

http://forum.purseblog.com/hermes/your-hermes-in-action-433311-113.html

Personally, I don't think there is really any right or wrong size with Birkins, it's more an individual preference. ;)
 
#7
I agree! Size is a matter of preference. I don't think a 35 is too big at all for your size. I like both sizes and think they fit different uses. For me, a 30 is a better transitional size from day to evening. I can fit all my daily stuff in a 30, but when I need to carry more, I reach for a 35.
 
#8
personally i think 35cm is PERFECT! and i'm not so tall myself, i've found my 40cm blue jean annoying =/ i wish it was HAC its funny because i tried on a 50CM Travel Birkin and i did not find it too big at all(maybe because i love HAC) but a 35cm is perfect not too big not too small i personally wouldn't do a 30cm unless it was ostrich or croc
 
#9
There is really no such thing as too big. It depends on the function, and if you prefer the tote look or pursey look. Make a real-sized cutout of cardboard of both 30 and 35 if you are unable to get a real birkin to compare. Do note that the weight difference will not be reflected in a cardboard mockup. I was initially aghast at the weight of my 35 but I've since gotten used to it.
 
#10
My personal opinion is that it isn't a matter of your size but what type of bag you want. The 30 is like a handbag and the 35 is more of a tote. .....

If you wear a lot of dresses and are "girly" ... go with 30.
If you are more casual and wear jeans and pants a lot ... go with 35.
If you want a bag to go from day to evening ... go with 30
If you want a bag to schlep papers to the office, carry magazines, etc. ... go with 35

I've had both and now only 35s. I am 5'1" ...
 
#11
Kallie Girl said:
My personal opinion is that it isn't a matter of your size but what type of bag you want. The 30 is like a handbag and the 35 is more of a tote. .....

If you wear a lot of dresses and are "girly" ... go with 30.
If you are more casual and wear jeans and pants a lot ... go with 35.
If you want a bag to go from day to evening ... go with 30
If you want a bag to schlep papers to the office, carry magazines, etc. ... go with 35

I've had both and now only 35s. I am 5'1" ...
Click to expand...

Very well said, kallie Girl !:smile1:
 
#13
I'm similar in height and cannot deal with a 35 because 1) it's just too heavey 2)DH says it looks like I'm rubbing a bank:p

It's definitely a personal choice and what your style is. I find the 30 to fit me perfectly, not too big, not to sporty, a little more girly~~
 
#14
I'd suggest you go to the boutique to check the sizes out ..as other ladies commented on, it is really a personal preference. IMHO, 35 looks a bit boxy if you wear dressy outfits.
 
#15
Lyanna Stark said:
There is really no such thing as too big. It depends on the function, and if you prefer the tote look or pursey look. Make a real-sized cutout of cardboard of both 30 and 35 if you are unable to get a real birkin to compare. Do note that the weight difference will not be reflected in a cardboard mockup. I was initially aghast at the weight of my 35 but I've since gotten used to it.
Click to expand...

sorry OT, but I used to carry Balenciaga weekenders (45 cm) and they hold ALOT, and when stuffed they are very heavy so I was pleasantly surprised at how light my Birkin actually felt!:smile1:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top