2 Guccis or 1 Chanel flap?

Would you rather have 2 Gucci bags, Dionysus and Padlock or 1 Chanel flap?

  • 2 Guccis

    Votes: 11 31.4%
  • 1 Chanel flap

    Votes: 24 68.6%

  • Total voters
    35
  • Poll closed .

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I would buy a Chanel flap without even thinking, however if I had to choose 2 Gucci bags I would pick a small GG Marmont in white leather (which is my favorite Gucci bag) and probably a Dionysus in small size, however I'm not sure about material or colour.
 
I already have plenty of both brands and all I can say is the only difference is the price.

I'd rather have one higher price range and exclusive Gucci rather than normal Chanel flap or 2 more commercial Guccis. Lower price point bags subsidise the higher.
 
I already have plenty of both brands and all I can say is the only difference is the price.

I'd rather have one higher price range and exclusive Gucci rather than normal Chanel flap or 2 more commercial Guccis. Lower price point bags subsidise the higher.

Interesting. Now I have few Guccis, LVs and Fendi and thinking all the time I could have rather invested in Chanel bags but maybe it’s just because of the hype. Also I made a mistake last year with not so cheap Fendi losing its shape already. I like commercial Guccis, I don’t even dare to think about exclusive for now ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: papertiger
Interesting. Now I have few Guccis, LVs and Fendi and thinking all the time I could have rather invested in Chanel bags but maybe it’s just because of the hype. Also I made a mistake last year with not so cheap Fendi losing its shape already. I like commercial Guccis, I don’t even dare to think about exclusive for now ;)
May I ask you which Fendi bag lost its shape?
 
Fendi Dotcom Click medium. Corners started to sag, I’m afraid it’s only going to get worse. They even discontinued it recently. I love the bag and wear it very often so I’m so sorry about it.
I understand perfectly. I get so frustrated when my bags lose shape or get scratched. That's why I recommend getting a Chanel flap, especially in caviar, however I'm not an expert of Gucci bags to say how durable they are. However, even if Gucci bags are as durable as Chanel, I would still advise getting Chanel, as they have more classic designs which you are not going to get bored of if you choose the right color and hardware for you. There was a time when I thought that the classic flap was overrated but the minute I saw it at the Chanel boutique for the first time I realized why everybody's in love with it. Anyway, good luck with your next purchase!
 
I understand perfectly. I get so frustrated when my bags lose shape or get scratched. That's why I recommend getting a Chanel flap, especially in caviar, however I'm not an expert of Gucci bags to say how durable they are. However, even if Gucci bags are as durable as Chanel, I would still advise getting Chanel, as they have more classic designs which you are not going to get bored of if you choose the right color and hardware for you. There was a time when I thought that the classic flap was overrated but the minute I saw it at the Chanel boutique for the first time I realized why everybody's in love with it. Anyway, good luck with your next purchase!

Thank you! I didn’t have any problem with my Guccis yet, they are pretty new. Last time I looked bags in caviar at the Chanel, they looked somehow dull but I read not all the batches are the same. Looking forward to find my beautiful Chanel flap once :)
 

Attachments

  • 27AB2013-6075-47C8-931F-C1605801844C.jpeg
    27AB2013-6075-47C8-931F-C1605801844C.jpeg
    89.5 KB · Views: 551
Thank you! I didn’t have any problem with my Guccis yet, they are pretty new. Last time I looked bags in caviar at the Chanel, they looked somehow dull but I read not all the batches are the same. Looking forward to find my beautiful Chanel flap once :smile:
I understand perfectly. I get so frustrated when my bags lose shape or get scratched. That's why I recommend getting a Chanel flap, especially in caviar, however I'm not an expert of Gucci bags to say how durable they are. However, even if Gucci bags are as durable as Chanel, I would still advise getting Chanel, as they have more classic designs which you are not going to get bored of if you choose the right color and hardware for you. There was a time when I thought that the classic flap was overrated but the minute I saw it at the Chanel boutique for the first time I realized why everybody's in love with it. Anyway, good luck with your next purchase!

Haha, by accident I posted exclusive Gucci Dionysus, sorry :D Talking about bag I like very much but wonder what will I think about it in a year, not to mention matching it with clothes... Chanel flap wins in those categories certainly...
 
I voted for Chanel, but really I'd advise getting the 1 bag you love the most right now (and is affordable/worth it to you). Just because you have x amount to spend, doesn't mean you have to spend it all right now. Buy 1 bag, enjoy it for awhile, then worry about the next one!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2gr8 and lana19
I voted for Chanel, but really I'd advise getting the 1 bag you love the most right now (and is affordable/worth it to you). Just because you have x amount to spend, doesn't mean you have to spend it all right now. Buy 1 bag, enjoy it for awhile, then worry about the next one!

Yes, thanks! I tend to overthink about bags, much more than shoes or clothes.
 
I love both brands and own bags from each. I can say my HG bag is my Jumbo Chanel Classic double flap, I adore that bag. I would get the bag that is the most difficult to obtain and then work on others at a later date.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lana19
I vote chanel. Price increases are hard to stomach. If you can get one now, do so... before it’s TOO LATE -cue funny horror movie sound effects-

Om my :D I get pretty scared every time I hear about price increase. I see Chanel turning into Hermès....

I love both brands and own bags from each. I can say my HG bag is my Jumbo Chanel Classic double flap, I adore that bag. I would get the bag that is the most difficult to obtain and then work on others at a later date.

Thanks, those are very strong arguments!
 
Top