five star thread, HG!
my preferences differ depending on the style, color and intended use of the bag. for a black kelly, box and only box; for a brown kelly, then i think chamonix -- though i've never actually seen it. in colors i like chevre for a kelly, with the exception of the orange/red/brown tricolor i'm getting -- in that case i prefer the togo for the casual and funky nature of the combination.
now for a picotin, i think that would just be kind of silly in box or chevre irrespective of the color -- there i'd go with barenia, which i've never seen but am SURE i would adore! any one of the softer textured leathers would be second choice.
for a bolide, my dream bag is that green croc that's on ebay right now. don't know why, but i just think croc and bolide is fabulous.
for a birkin, ostrich or chevre -- i want it to be light, light, light and retain its shape. box comes in second (third?) for the glow.
and finally, i want something -- ANYTHING-- in bleu sapphir fjord like orchid's georgeous bag.
i think what this says about me is that i'm fickle! and a glutton!