I LOVE the large Carly. I have it in black leather and the canvas with pear trim. They are big but I don't feel like I am carrying luggage because they hug you nicely. That said, all the bags on your list are great and the patent Ergo also sounds like something to consider. This is a good problem to have!!
That is a shame about your Ali. I would have to say the camel Carly and it is a classic and the leather will last for a very long time and goes with almost everything.
i'm just kinda sad because i missed out on my chance for the PH leather one, and i love the angora colored wristlet...i would want it to match with my bag
do you think camel color would look nice with the angora?