This is so weird! I called my outlet Weds. and told them about the Pac-man items that came damaged (well, defective, really) from FOS, and she said she could hold some for 48 hours under my name, so I'm picking them up tonight.
Well, first I asked her if they had a lot of them (deciding whether I should take my chances waiting till I could come in tonight, etc.), and she offered to find me "good" ones to hold (i.e. the ghosts weren't faded). I guess every store is different, but it sounds like your store is more strict.
I thought 48 hours was the norm - a few weeks ago the other local outlet in my area held an emoji bag charm for me when I stupidly left the store w/o it and had non-buyer's remorse
They didn't tell me about the return period changing to 30 days, but I believe it.... the rumors were flying in the return policy thread a couple weeks back!