I also think the luxe flap in silver had some rubbing issues (the gold bowlers did, and when I returned mine, I was told that the silver did too - not good). Personally, I prefer the dark silver reissue to the light silver, but between your choices, I would choose the light silver reissue!
But will it be too much if I already have the gold and the navy patent, then I will have a light silver reissue too? Or should I get another style since I don't have any other styles rather than the medium flap and reissue?!