You really can't go wrong with either style - however, that said, the birkin IMO is great as an open tote - easy to get in and out of (of course you can close it) and I am 5'2" and love the 30cm size! One of the best part of Hermes bags are their colors, which can put the "funk" in there for you! The brights are beautiful -- the kellys are also great, the 28 might be a little small if you carry a lot -- you can always add the "funk" in a kelly too by getting and ostrich!! Oh boy...here we go lol!!! Check out e-bay for colors and sizes, and look through the past posts for comparisons... and WELCOME!