I think the giant gold hardware on the Balenciaga is going to look dated more quickly than the Chanel, so I'd say keep the Chanel.
the Chanel, for sure. Then again, I am not a fan of Bal bags at all, so I am biased.
I'm definitely the minority but I'd keep the Cambon tote for longevity reasons. out of the two, I still think the tote will be more of a classic than the GH Bbags. If you want the most wanted bag at the moment (I mean that in a good way) then keep the cafe giant part-time