I have bought a total of six bags from Eva (authentic_lvlady) - never have had any of them have any kind of smell. I do know I have heard that epi leather even new in the store can have a "cat pee smell." It is the epi leather from what I understand. My bags have all been great from her. No smell even holding them directly under my nose - but they were all monogram. I do think there can be a kind of scent from other countries (I used to live in India when I was little). It should air out. I don't know about epi leather though because I've heard this from other buyers even new. I think if you do a search for "cat pee smell" with "Epi," you may find lots of posts, not related to any one seller. There are some tips on how to deal with it.