I would say the legacy shoulder bag style 11127 in BLACK LEATHER!!! This bag is my birthday present, and hubby is giving it to me one month early next Wed!!! I cant wait to use it! I, too, fell IN LOVE w/ the Legacy line, and when I saw THIS bag and tried her on it was INSTANT love! I LOVE the black legacy leather b/c it is the easiest color to take care of..and it doesnt show ANY dirt or scratches!!! Good luck w/ your decision and PLEASE keep us posted!!!