Although it depends on the color, I generally prefer the twiggy, especially in fun colors like this and would pay more if I had a choice. I tend to lean toward the city on darker, neutral colors since i carry my computer in them. Unfortunately, there seem to be more cities around, so most of the colorful bags I have are in the city style (I don't know why, but the extended zippers bug me). It's extremely rare to see this specific color in impeccable condition and in the twiggy style. Whoever wins this will have a serious gem! I just say get the style if you love it and not worry about what others think are more "popular". Not that it should matter, but I don't see a big difference in resale value, I just think the auctions on one outweigh the other.