HELP me choose boots

both are cute-- I noticed that one has a 12" cir. and the other a 15 inch circ. That may be a deciding factor if you plan to tuck your jeans in... just a thought.

12 seems REALLY tiny to me!!! Then again, you may have teeny legs!
 
While I love the simple classic lines of the Weitzman's, there is no way you will be able to get jeans tucked into them unless you have toothpick legs.

I just bought my first pair of Modern Vintage booties (below), and I can honestly say that I was blown away by the quality (beautifully leather lined), the feel of the soft leather, and the fit. They were designed for my foot. IMO, you can't go wrong with the MV, plus they will most likely allow jeans to be tucked into them.