I was just offered a togo Raisin retourne 25 and honestly it was ridiculous on me. I am 5'3" and 140 pounds and it looks awful. Even my hand looked large holding it. My dogon wallet didn't even fit inside it not to mention trying to get keys and cellular and other things I need with me each day. I can just imagine how tight a 25 rigide in Box leather would be.
I think you made the wise decision passing, although I sympathize with you on the empty feeling. I always feel awful turning down a Kelly - regardless of the size and color. It feels almost like a betrayal to such an object of beauty. But I know a 28 would look amazing on you and you would completely love it. Just enjoy the bags you have while your SO gets made with all the love from the craftsman.